Résumés
Abstract
In this paper, we build on critical scholarship calling for a care revolution in geography by examining the comprehensive/qualifying exam (QE) process as a moment of intervention. In North America, aspiring doctoral candidates are typically expected to pass a QE before beginning their research. The way QEs are traditionally designed and implemented in the field of geography reinforces a particular canon and a certain way of being a geographer that excludes diverse knowledges. Doctoral students often experience preparing for and completing these exams as a specifically stressful and isolating period. Such an approach to QEs limits geography’s potential as a caring discipline. From our positions as a doctoral student and PhD supervisor, we use collaborative autoethnography to explore an alternative QE format. To better understand the potential of alternative QEs to support doctoral education in geography, we bring literature on QEs into conversation with feminist geography literature on care and academia, exploring the educational possibilities of practicing QEs in a way aligned with a caring academic praxis. Rather than being viewed as a rigorous and individualized test focused on creating ‘expert geographers,’ we suggest the discipline thinks about QEs as a process that encourages scholars to practically and relationally engage with diverse ways of knowing. Despite its potential, doing QEs differently within an uncaring university system can be challenging. It requires a great deal of relational care work to be done well. In conclusion, we consider how geographers might begin to practice QEs differently in order to imagine the discipline, and academia, otherwise.
Keywords:
- doctoral education,
- qualifying examination,
- caring university,
- feminist geography
Parties annexes
Bibliography
- Adams-Hutcheson, Gail, and Lynda Johnston. 2019. "Flourishing in Fragile Academic Work Spaces and Learning Environments: Feminist Geographies of Care and Mentoring." Gender, Place & Culture 26 (4): 451-467.
- Bartos, Ann E. 2021. "Troubling False Care: Towards a More Revolutionary ‘Care Revolution’ in the University," ACME: An International Journal for Critical Geographies 20 (3): 312-321.
- Cannon, Susan Ophelia. 2020. "Making Kin with Comprehensive Exams: Producing Scholar in Intra-action," Qualitative Inquiry 26 (1): 36-50.
- Capello, Sarah A. 2023. "Linking Assessments to Program Outcomes in Practitioner Oriented EdD Programs: An Alternative to Comprehensive Examinations,” Journal of Adult and Continuing Education 29(1): 25-40.
- Coia, Lesley, and Monica Taylor. 2013. "Uncovering Our Feminist Pedagogy: A Co/autoethnography," Studying Teacher Education 9 (1): 3-17.
- Dinsmore, Brooke, and Josipa Roksa. 2023. “Inequalities in Becoming a Scholar: Race, Gender and Student-advisor Relationships in Doctoral Education,” Teachers College Record 125 (9): 84-107.
- Dowler, Lorraine, Dana Cuomo, A.M. Ranjbar, Nicole Laliberte, and Jenna Christian. 2019. “Care,” Keywords in Radical Geography: Antipode at 50: 35-39.
- Fisher, Rick, Cynthia H. Brock, T. Frahm, A. Van Wig, and V. R. Gillis. 2020. "Reflections on Writing and Identity: Exploring the Role of Qualifying Exams in the Sociocultural Development of Doctoral Students," Studies in Continuing Education 42 (3): 365-380.
- Gieseking, Jack Jen. 2023. “Reflections on a Cis Discipline," Environment and Planning D: Society and Space 41 (4): 571-591.
- Guloy, Sheryl, Gregory Hum, and D. Kevin O’Neill. 2020. "Voices at the Gate: Faculty Members’ and Students’ Differing Perspectives on the Purposes of the PhD Comprehensive Examination," Assessment & Evaluation in Higher Education 45 (2): 279-291.
- Hamilton, Trina, Roberta Hawkins, and Margaret Walton-Roberts. 2021. “Canon, Legacy or Imprint: A Feminist Reframing of Intellectual Contribution.” In Reimagining the Academy: ShiFting Towards Kindness, Connection, and an Ethics of Care, edited by Alison L. Black and Rachael Dwyer, 327-347. London: Palgrave Macmillan.
- Hawkins, Roberta, Karen Falconer Al‐Hindi, Pamela Moss, and Leslie Kern. 2016. “Practicing Collective Biography,” Geography Compass 10 (4): 165-178.
- Hawkins, Roberta and Leslie Kern. 2024. Higher Expectations: How to survive academia, make it better for others and transform the university. Toronto: Between the Lines Books.
- Hawkins, Roberta, Maya Manzi, and Diana Ojeda. 2014. "Lives in the Making: Power, Academia and the Everyday," ACME: An International Journal for Critical Geographies 13 (2): 328-351.
- Humphreys, Michael. 2005. "Getting Personal: Reflexivity and Autoethnographic Vignettes," Qualitative Inquiry 11 (6): 840-860.
- Kinkaid, Eden, and Lauren Fritzsche. 2022. "The Stories We Tell: Challenging Exclusionary Histories of Geography in US Graduate Curriculum," Annals of the American Association of Geographers 112 (8): 2469-2485.
- Kostohryz, Katie. 2016. "The Doctoral Comprehensive Examination in Counselor Education: Faculty Members’ Perception of its Purposes," Journal of Counselor Preparation and Supervision 8(3): 6.
- McAdams III, Charles R., and Derek L. Robertson. 2012. "An Informed Look at Doctoral Vivas (Oral Examinations) in the Preparation of Counselor Educators," Counselor Education and Supervision 51 (3): 176-188.
- McLaughlin, Jacqueline E., Kathryn Morbitzer, Margaux Meilhac, Natalie Poupart, Rebekah L. Layton, and Michael B. Jarstfer. 2024. "Standards Needed? An Exploration of Qualifying Exams from a Literature Review and Website Analysis of University-wide Policies," Studies in Graduate and Postdoctoral Education 15 (1): 19-33.
- Moss, Pamela, and Kathryn Besio. 2019. “Auto-methods in Feminist Geography,” GeoHumanities, 5 (2): 313-325.
- Mott, Carrie, and Daniel Cockayne. 2017. "Citation Matters: Mobilizing the Politics of Citation Toward a Practice of ‘Conscientious Engagement,’" Gender, Place & Culture 24 (7): 954-973.
- Mountz, Alison, Anne Bonds, Becky Mansfield, Jenna Loyd, Jennifer Hyndman, Margaret Walton-Roberts, Ranu Basu et al. 2015. "For Slow Scholarship: A Feminist Politics of Resistance Through Collective Action in the Neoliberal University," ACME: An International Journal for Critical Geographies 14 (4): 1235-1259.
- Oswin, Natalie. 2020. "An Other Geography," Dialogues in Human Geography 10 (1): 9-18.
- Shields, Sara Scott. 2015. "Like Climbing Jacob’s Ladder: An Art-based Exploration of the Comprehensive Exam Process," Arts and Humanities in Higher Education 14 (2): 206-227.
- Stewart-Wells, A. Gillian, and K. Mallery Keenan. 2020. "Assessing Doctoral Students: A Background on Comprehensive and Authentic Assessments," The Journal of Continuing Higher Education 68 (2): 84-100.
- Sverdlik, Anna, and Nathan C. Hall. 2020. "Not Just a Phase: Exploring the Role of Program Stage on Well-being and Motivation in Doctoral Students," Journal of Adult and Continuing Education 26 (1): 97-124.
- Smyth, Araby, Jess Linz, and Lauren Hudson. 2020. "A Feminist Coven in the University," Gender, Place & Culture 27 (6): 854-880.
- Taylor, Yvette, and Kinneret Lahad. 2018. Feeling academic in the neoliberal university: Feminist flights, fights and failures. Cham: Springer International Publishing.
- Wood, Lydia, Kate Swanson, and Donald E. Colley III. 2020. "Tenets for a Radical Care Ethics in Geography." ACME: An International Journal for Critical Geographies 19 (2): 424-447.
- Wood, Patricia. 2015. "Contemplating the Value of Comprehensive Exams: Do They have a Role in a Radical Agenda for Reimagining the PhD in the Neoliberal University?" GeoJournal 80 (2): 225-229.

