Résumés
Abstract
Transparency reports are public documents released by companies such as Google, Facebook, and Verizon that contain extensive information regarding data privacy. For instance, these reports document the number of times a law enforcement agency requests user information from a specific company. Transparency reports exist at the nexus of a complex “digital responsibility” relationship between “Big Tech” firms and governments that want the data they collect. We offer the only known systematic analysis of US requests for user information; we use data from over 250 transparency reports provided by fifteen companies from 2010 to 2022 to document nearly eleven million legal requests, national security requests, location requests, and users affected by requests. We also review evidence from content analysis of reports from technology companies. The results suggest that the US government has grown ever more dependent on these companies over time, with an average 759 percent increase in requests for information. In sum, the changing nature of US law enforcement and national security requests reveals a “responsibility dilemma” for companies providing the most personalized technology services.
Keywords:
- transparency reports,
- responsibility,
- data privacy,
- Big Tech,
- Google,
- Facebook,
- Verizon,
- federal government,
- information requests
Parties annexes
Bibliography
- Access Now. 2021. "Transparency Reporting Index." https://www.accessnow.org/campaign/transparency-reporting-index/.
- Achiam, Josh, Steven Adler, Sandhini Agarwal, Lama Ahmad, Ilge Akkaya, Florencia Leoni Aleman, Diogo Almeida, Janko Altenschmidt, Sam Altman, and Shyamal Anadkat. 2023. "GPT-4 Technical Report." arXiv preprint arXiv:2303.08774.
- Al‐Ubaydli, Omar, and Patrick A. McLaughlin. 2017. "RegData: A Numerical Database on Industry‐Specific Regulations for all United States Industries and Federal Regulations, 1997–2012." Regulation & Governance 11 (1): 109-123.
- Albu, Oana Brindusa, and Mikkel Flyverbom. 2019. "Organizational Transparency: Conceptualizations, Conditions, and Consequences." Business & society 58 (2):268-297.
- Anastasopoulos, L Jason, and Andrew B Whitford. 2019. "Machine Learning for Public Administration Research, with Application to Organizational Reputation." Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory 29 (3):491-510.
- Anderson, Patrick. 2022. "Of Cypherpunks and Sousveillance." Surveillance & Society 20 (1):1-17.
- Armantier, Olivier, Sebastian Doerr, Jon Frost, Andreas Fuster, and Kelly Shue. 2021. Whom do Consumers Trust with Their Data? US survey evidence. Bank for International Settlements.
- Ballard, Ben, and Christopher Parsons. 2021. "Mixed Traditions: Evaluating Telecommunications Transparency." Internet Policy Review 11 (1):1-30.
- Bazargan, Saba. 2013. "Complicitous Liability in War." Philosophical Studies 165:177-195. doi: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11098-012-9927-2.
- Berman, Emily. 2016. "Quasi-Constitutional Protections and Government Surveillance." BYU L. Rev.:771.
- Bond, Robert M., Christopher J. Fariss, Jason J. Jones, Adam D. I. Kramer, Cameron Marlow, Jaime E. Settle, and James H. Fowler. 2012. "A 61-Million-Person Experiment in Social Influence and Political Mobilization." Nature 489 (7415):295-298. doi: 10.1038/nature11421.
- Cole, David D. 2016. "After Snowden: Regulating Technology-Aided Surveillance in the Digital Age." Cap. UL Rev. 44:677.
- Colquitt, Jason A. 2001. "On the Dimensionality of Organizational Justice: A Construct Validation of a Measure." Journal of applied psychology 86 (3):386.
- Ebert, Isabel. 2024. "Responding to Unusual Government Request for User Data: How Tech Companies Make Sense of Human Rights." Big Data & Society 11 (1):20539517241232638.
- Farivar, Cyrus. 2018. Habeas data: privacy vs. the rise of surveillance tech: Melville House Publishing.
- Felzmann, Heike, Eduard Fosch Villaronga, Christoph Lutz, and Aurelia Tamò-Larrieux. 2019. "Transparency You Can Trust: Transparency Requirements for Artificial Intelligence Between Legal Norms and Contextual Concerns." Big Data & Society 6 (1):2053951719860542.
- Flyverbom, Mikkel. 2015. "Sunlight in Cyberspace? On Transparency as a Form of Ordering." European journal of social theory 18 (2):168-184.
- Flyverbom, Mikkel. 2016. "Transparency: Mediation and the Management of Visibilities." International Journal of Communication 10 (1):110-122.
- Flyverbom, Mikkel. 2019. The Digital Prism: Cambridge University Press.
- Gu, Hongfei. 2023. "Data, Big Tech, and the New Concept of Sovereignty." Journal of Chinese Political Science. doi: 10.1007/s11366-023-09855-1.
- Heimstädt, Maximilian, and Leonhard Dobusch. 2020. "Transparency and Accountability: Causal, Critical and Constructive Perspectives." Organization Theory 1 (4):2631787720964216.
- Herden, Christina J., Ervin Alliu, André Cakici, Thibaut Cormier, Catherine Deguelle, Sahil Gambhir, Caleb Griffiths, Shrishti Gupta, Sahil R. Kamani, Yonca-Selda Kiratli, Máté Kispataki, Greta Lange, Leandro Moles De Matos, Laura Tripero Moreno, Hector Alain Betancourt Nunez, Venkata Pilla, Bairesh Raj, James Roe, Markus Skoda, Youye Song, Praveen Kumar Ummadi, and Laura Marie Edinger-Schons. 2021. "Corporate Digital Responsibility." Sustainability Management Forum | NachhaltigkeitsManagementForum 29 (1):13-29. doi: 10.1007/s00550-020-00509-x.
- Hovyadinov, Sergei. 2019. "Toward a More Meaningful Transparency: Examining Twitter, Google, and Facebook’s Transparency Reporting and Removal Practices in Russia." Google, and Facebook’s Transparency Reporting and Removal Practices in Russia (November 30, 2019).
- Jensen, Morten Højer. 2020. "Complicity and the Responsibility Dilemma." Philosophical Studies 177 (1):109-127. doi: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11098-018-1182-8.
- Johnston, Michael. 2006. "Good Governance: Rule of Law, Transparency, and Accountability." New York: United Nations Public Administration Network:1-32.
- Kosta, Eleni, and Magdalena Brewczyńska. 2019. "Government Access to User Data: Towards More Meaningful Transparency Reports." In Regulating Industrial Internet Through IPR, Data Protection and Competition Law, edited by R Ballardini, P Kuoppamäki & O Pitkänen, 253-274. KLUWER LAW INT.
- Kosters, Lisa, and Oskar Josef Gstrein. 2024. "TikTok and Transparency Obligations in the EU Digital Services Act (DSA)–A Scoping Review." Zeitschrift für Europarechtliche Studien (ZEuS) 27 (1):110-145.
- Larsson, Stefan, and Fredrik Heintz. 2020. "Transparency in Artificial Intelligence." Internet policy review 9 (2).
- Lazar, Seth. 2010. "The Responsibility Dilemma for Killing in War: A Review Essay." Philosophy & Public Affairs 38 (2):180-213. doi: https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1088-4963.2010.01182.x.
- Le Mens, Gaël, Balázs Kovács, Michael T Hannan, and Guillem Pros. 2023. "Uncovering the Semantics of Concepts Using GPT-4." Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 120 (49):e2309350120.
- Levenson, Eric, and Kristina Segueglia. 2023. "These are the Google Searches Brian Walshe Made Before and After Killing His Wife Ana Walshe, According to Prosecutors." CNN. Accessed 3/17/2023. https://www.cnn.com/2023/01/18/us/brian-walshe-ana-walshe-google-searches/index.html.
- Lindman, Juho, Jukka Makinen, and Eero Kasanen. 2023. "Big Tech’s Power, Political Corporate Social Responsibility and Regulation." Journal of Information Technology:02683962221113596.
- Llanos, J. 2021. Transparency Reporting: Considerations for the Review of the OECD Privacy Guidelines.
- Lobschat, Lara, Benjamin Mueller, Felix Eggers, Laura Brandimarte, Sarah Diefenbach, Mirja Kroschke, and Jochen Wirtz. 2021. "Corporate Digital Responsibility." Journal of Business Research 122:875-888.
- Maalsen, Sophia, and Jathan Sadowski. 2019. "The Smart Home on FIRE: Amplifying and Accelerating Domestic Surveillance." Surveillance & Society 17 (1/2):118-124.
- Marx, Gary T. 2016. Windows into the Soul: Surveillance and Society in an Age of High Technology: The University of Chicago Press.
- McMahan, Jeff. 2009. Killing in War: OUP UK.
- Mejias, Ulises A, and Nick Couldry. 2024. "Data Grab: The New Colonialism of Big Tech and How to Fight Back." In Data Grab. University of Chicago Press.
- Parsons, Christopher. 2019. "The (in) Effectiveness of Voluntarily Produced Transparency Reports." Business & Society 58 (1):103-131.
- Quinn, Kevin M, Burt L Monroe, Michael Colaresi, Michael H Crespin, and Dragomir R Radev. 2010. "How to Analyze Political Attention with Minimal Assumptions and Costs." American Journal of Political Science 54 (1):209-228.
- Reid, Amanda, Evan Ringel, and Shanetta M Pendleton. 2023. "Transparency Reports as CSR Reports: Motives, Stakeholders, and Strategies." Social Responsibility Journal.
- Schneider, Anne, and Helen Ingram. 1993. "Social Construction of Target Populations: Implications for Politics and Policy." American political science review 87 (2):334-347.
- Soghoian, Christopher. 2011. "An End to Privacy Theater: Exposing and Discouraging Corporate Disclosure of User Data to the Government." Minn. JL Sci. & Tech. 12:191.
- Stark, David, and Ivana Pais. 2020. "Algorithmic Management in the Platform Economy." Sociologica 14 (3):47-72.
- Urman, Aleksandra, and Mykola Makhortykh. 2023. "How Transparent are Transparency Reports? Comparative Analysis of Transparency Reporting Across Online Platforms." Telecommunications Policy:102477.
- Van Der Merwe, Joanna, and Ziad Al Achkar. 2022. "Data Responsibility, Corporate Social Responsibility, and Corporate Digital Responsibility." Data & Policy 4. doi: 10.1017/dap.2022.2.
- Walker-Munro, Brendan. 2023. "Hyper-Collection: A Possible New Paradigm in Modern Surveillance." Surveillance & society 21 (2):120-138.
- Whitford, Andrew B, and Jeff Yates. 2022. "Surveillance and Privacy as Coevolving Disruptions: Reflections on “Notice and Choice”." Policy Design and Practice:1-13.
- Wolf, Christopher. 2013. "An Analysis of Service Provider Transparency Reports on Government Requests for Data." A Hogan Lovells White Paper 8 (27):1-6.
- Wood, David Murakami, and Valerie Steeves. 2021. "Smart Surveillance." Surveillance & Society 19 (2):150-153.
- Woolery, Liz, Ryan Budish, and Kevin Bankston. 2016. "The Transparency Reporting Toolkit." New America and The Berkman Center for Internet & Society at Harvard University.
- Yates, Jeff, and Andrew B Whitford. 2022. "Surveillance as the Past and Future of Public Administration." Perspectives on Public Management and Governance. doi: https://doi.org/10.1093/ppmgov/gvac022.

