Résumés
Abstract
Monitored ceasefires are thought to be more robust ceasefires, with less noncompliance by conflict parties. Ceasefires monitored with remote sensing technology (RST) such as imaging satellites, uncrewed aerial vehicles, and other camera-equipped assets are widely seen as more effective in deterring conflict party noncompliance. Drawing on insights from surveillance studies, especially from the logics of resistance to surveillance, I argue that the opposite outcome can occur: the use and presence of RST in monitoring may also contribute to new ceasefire noncompliance in the form of new violence. Taking a primarily abductive approach, I theorize how such noncompliance may be produced, identifying four mechanisms. First, the use of RST creates a new class of lower-cost ceasefire violations. Second, the presence of third-party RST incentivizes conflict parties to test the sophistication of monitors’ surveillance. Third, the use of RST by monitors can devalue classical, low-tech monitoring methods. Fourth, the use of RST may inadvertently improve conflict parties’ military abilities. Building on insights from fifty-two interviews and written exchanges with former ceasefire monitors, I demonstrate the presence of these mechanisms in the case of the most technologically advanced ceasefire monitoring mission yet deployed, the Special Monitoring Mission in Ukraine, focusing on the period prior to the Russian invasion of 2022.
Keywords:
- ceasefire monitoring,
- compliance,
- remote sensing,
- UAVs,
- uncrewed aerial vehicles,
- remote sensing technologies,
- Ukraine
Parties annexes
Bibliography
- African Union. 2022. Agreement for lasting peace through a permanent cessation of hostilities between the Government of the Federal Democratic Republic of Ethiopia and the Tigray People’s Liberation Front (TPLF). Addis Ababa.
- Apakan, Ertuğrul, and Cono Giardullo. 2020. UAVs for the benefit of people: the use of unmanned aerial vehicles within the OSCE Special Monitoring Mission. Human Rights Quarterly 42 (2): 479-487.
- Avtar, Ram, Asma Kouser, Ashwani Kumar, et al. 2021. Remote sensing for international peace and security: its role and implications. Remote Sensing 13 (3): 439.
- Bennett, Colin J. 2008. The privacy advocates: resisting the spread of surveillance. Cambridge: MIT Press.
- Boyle, Michael J. 2020. The drone age: How drone technology will change war and peace. New York: Oxford University Press.
- Buchanan, Cate, Govinda Clayton, and Alexander Ramsbotham. 2021. Ceasefire monitoring: Developments and complexities. London: Conciliation Resources.
- Coleman, Roy, and Michael McCahill. 2011. Surveillance & crime. London: Sage Publications.
- De Santis, Hugh. 1990. Commercial observation satellites, alliance relations, and the developing world. In Commercial observation satellites and international security, edited by Michael Krepon, Peter Zimmerman, Leonard Spector, and Mary Umberger, 78-89. Basingstoke: Macmillan.
- Diehl, Paul F. 2002. The political implications of using new technologies in peace operations. International Peacekeeping 9 (3): 1-24.
- Dorn, A. Walter. 2004. Blue sensors: Technology and cooperative monitoring in UN peacekeeping. CMC Occasional Papers, Albuquerque: Sandia National Laboratories.
- Dorn, A. Walter, and Cono Giardullo. 2020. Analysis for peace: The evolving data tools of UN and OSCE field operations. Security and Human Rights 31 (1-4): 90-101.
- Edwards, Scott, and Christoph Koettl. 2011. Looking to the sky: Monitoring human rights through remote sensing. Harvard International Review 32 (4): 66-71.
- Fernandez, Luis A., and Laura Huey. 2009. Is resistance futile? Some thoughts on resisting surveillance. Surveillance & Society 6 (3): 198-202.
- Fortna, Virginia Page. 2004. Peace time: Cease-fire agreements and the durability of peace. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
- Foucault, Michel. 1975. Surveiller et punir: naissance de la prison. Paris: Gallimard.
- Giardullo, Cono, Walter Dorn, and Danielle Stodilka. 2020. Technological innovation in the OSCE: The Special Monitoring Mission in Ukraine. In OSCE Yearbook 2019, edited by IFSH, 119-37. Baden-Baden: Nomos.
- Grand-Clément, Sarah. 2022. Exploring the use of technology for remote ceasefire monitoring and verification. Geneva: UNIDIR.
- Haggerty, Kevin D. 2012. Surveillance, crime and the police. In Routledge handbook of surveillance studies, edited by David Lyon, Kevin D. Haggerty and Kirstie Ball, 235-243. Abingdon: Routledge.
- Haggerty, Kevin D., and Richard V. Ericson. 2001. The military technostructures of policing. In Militarizing the American criminal justice system: The changing roles of the armed forces and the police, edited by Peter Kraska, 43-64. Boston: Northeastern University Press.
- Harris, Chad. 2006. The omniscient eye: satellite imagery, “battlespace awareness,” and the structures of the imperial gaze. Surveillance and Society 4 (1-2): 101-122.
- Hedstrom, Peter, and Petri Ylikoski. 2010. Causal mechanisms in the social sciences. Annual Review of Sociology 36: 49-67.
- Hirblinger, Andreas T., Martin Wählisch, Kate Keator, et al. 2024. Making peace with un-certainty: Reflections on the role of digital technology in peace processes beyond the data hype. International Studies Perspectives 25 (2): 185-225.
- Hug, Alexander, and Simon Mason. 2022. Ceasefire monitoring and verification technology. CSS Policy Perspectives. Zurich: Center for Security Studies, ETH Zurich.
- Hug, Alexander. 2024. Ceasefire Monitoring and verification and the use of technology: Insights from Ukraine 2014-2022. Zurich: Center for Security Studies, ETH Zurich.
- Illari, Phyllis M., and Jon Williamson. 2012. What is a mechanism? Thinking about mechanisms across the sciences. European Journal for Philosophy of Science 2: 119-135.
- Karlsrud, John, and Frederik Rosén. 2013. In the eye of the beholder? The UN and the use of drones to protect civilians. Stability 2 (2): 1-10.
- Karlsrud, John, and Frederik Rosén. 2017. Lifting the fog of war? Opportunities and challenges of drones in UN peace operations. In The Good Drone, edited by Kristin Sandvik and Maria Jumbert, 45-63. Routledge.
- Kurgan, Laura. 2013. Close up at a distance: mapping, technology, and politics. New York: Zone Books.
- Lindley, Dan. 2006. Cooperative airborne monitoring: Opening the skies to promote peace, protect the environment, and cope with natural disasters. Contemporary Security Policy 27 (2): 325-343.
- Lindley, Dan. 2007. Promoting peace with information: Transparency as a tool of security regimes. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
- Luzin, Pavel. 2023. Russian military drones: Past, present, and future of the UAV industry. Philadelphia: Foreign Policy Research Institute.
- Lyon, David. 2001. Surveillance society: Monitoring everyday life. Buckingham: Open University Press.
- Marx, Andrew, and Samuel Goward. 2013. Remote sensing in human rights and international humanitarian law monitoring: Concepts and methods. Geographical Review 103 (1): 100-111.
- Marx, Gary T. 2003. Tack in the shoe: Neutralizing and resisting the new surveillance. Journal of Social Issues 59 (2): 369-390.
- Marx, Gary T. 2009. A tack in the shoe and taking off the shoe: Neutralization and counter-neutralization dynamics. Surveillance & Society 6 (3): 294-306.
- Marx, Gary T. 2014. Security and surveillance contests: Resistance and counter-resistance. In Contesting security, edited by Thierry Balzacq, 15-28. Abingdon: Routledge.
- Merriman, Peter. 2019. Relational governance, distributed agency and the unfolding of movements, habits and environments: Parking practices and regulations in England. EPC: Politics and Space 37 (8): 1400-1417.
- Merton, Robert. 1968. Social theory and social structure. New York: The Free Press.
- Monahan, Torin. 2006a. Counter-surveillance as political intervention? Social Semiotics 16 (4): 515-534.
- Monahan, Torin. 2006b. Questioning surveillance and security. In Surveillance and security: technological politics and power in everyday life, edited by Torin Monahan, 1-26. Abingdon: Routledge.
- Mulcahy, Linda. 2024. Modernisation or transformation? User led design and the facilitation of systemic change in the Traffic Penalty Tribunal. Civil Justice Quarterly 43 (2): 120-141.
- Naghizadeh, Mikael H. 2025. What we don’t see: Uncovering intercommunal violence through remote sensing. Political Geography 116: 103259.
- OSCE. 2015. Package of measures for the implementation of the Minsk agreements. https://www.osce.org/files/f/documents/5/b/140221.pdf [accessed February 24, 2025].
- OSCE. 2017. Newly installed OSCE SMM camera destroyed by small-arms fire in eastern Ukraine. https://www.osce.org/special-monitoring-mission-to-ukraine/335046 [accessed February 24, 2025].
- OSCE. 2021. A peaceful presence: The first five years of the OSCE Special Monitoring Mission to Ukraine. Vienna: OSCE.
- OSCE. 2022. 2021 Trends and observations from the Special Monitoring Mission to Ukraine. https://www.osce.org/special-monitoring-mission-to-ukraine/511327 [accessed February 24, 2025].
- Peško, Marcel. 2017. The OSCE’s engagement in response to the crisis in Ukraine: Meeting new challenges with new solutions. In OSCE Yearbook 2016, edited by IFSH, 23-32. Baden-Baden: Nomos.
- Pozzoni, Gianluca, and Tuukka Kaidesoja. 2021. Context in mechanism-based explanation. Philosophy of the Social Sciences 51 (6): 523-554.
- Raby, Rebecca. 2005. What is resistance? Journal of Youth Studies 8 (2): 151-171.
- Richmond, Oliver P., and Gëzim Visoka. 2021. Peace-making: New technologies are no panacea. Nature 590: 389.
- Salerno, Reynolds M., Michael G. Vannoni, David S. Barber, Randall R. Parish, and Rebecca L. Frerichs. 2000. Enhanced peacekeeping with monitoring technologies. Albuquerque: Cooperative Monitoring Center and International Security Center, Sandia National Laboratories.
- Sieber, Sam. 1981. Fatal remedies. New York: Plenum Press.
- Sticher, Valerie, and Aly Verjee. 2023. Do eyes in the sky ensure peace on the ground? The uncertain contributions of remote sensing to ceasefire compliance. International Studies Review 25 (3): viad039.
- Sticher, Valerie, Jan D. Wegner, and Birke Pfeifle. 2023. Toward the remote monitoring of armed conflicts. PNAS Nexus 2 (6): pgad181.
- Swed, Ori. 2020. Breaking the order: The intended and unintended consequences of countersurveillance on the West Bank. Surveillance & Society 18 (1): 48-60.
- TASS. 2021. Russian, Turkish servicemen use UAVs to monitor situation in Karabakh round the clock. 6 Feb. https://tass.com/world/1253347 [accessed February 24, 2025].
- Temple-Raston, Dina, and Will Jarvis. 2023. Tracking atrocities in Sudan: ‘The world has become significantly less anonymous for war criminals.’ The Record, June 27. https://therecord.media/tracking-atrocities-satellites-sudan-darfur-nathaniel-raymond-click-here [accessed February 24, 2025].
- Thornberg, Robert. 2012. Informed Grounded Theory. Scandinavian Journal of Educational Research 56 (3): 243–59.
- Timmermans, Stefan, and Iddo Tavory. 2012. Theory construction in qualitative research: From grounded theory to abductive analysis. Sociological Theory 30 (3): 167-186.
- United States Department of State. 2023. Briefing with senior State Department officials on the situation in Sudan. May 11. https://www.state.gov/briefing-with-senior-state-department-officials-on-the-situation-in-sudan/ [accessed February 24, 2025].
- Verjee, Aly. 2022. Ceasefire monitoring under fire: The OSCE, technology, and the 2022 war in Ukraine. Global Policy 13 (5): 808-817.
- Verjee, Aly. 2025. Theorizing conflict opponent noncompliance from ceasefire monitoring. Cooperation and Conflict. OnlineFirst.
- Verjee, Aly, and Valerie Sticher. 2024. Ambassador, you’re on mute: Methods for co-interviewing elites online. International Journal of Qualitative Methods 23.
- Wells, Helen. 2015. Getting around and getting on: Self-interested resistance to technology in law enforcement contexts. Annual Review of Law and Social Science 11: 175-192.
- Wells, Helen, and David Wills. 2009. Individualism and identity: Resistance to speed cameras in the UK. Surveillance and Society 6 (3): 259-274.
- Witmer, Frank D. W. 2015. Remote sensing of violent conflict: eyes from above. International Journal of Remote Sensing 36 (9): 2326-2352.
- Završnik, Aleš. 2015. Drones, resistance and countersurveillance. In Drones and unmanned aerial systems, edited by Aleš Završnik, 243-266. Cham: Springer.

