Résumés
Résumé
Des études sur l’altérisation en période d’épidémie montrent une instrumentalisation récurrente d’éclosions de maladies pour reproduire des exclusions raciales. Inspiré par les études du nouveau racisme et appuyé sur l’outil conceptuel du « racisme limite », cet article s’attarde à la normativité argumentative de cette exclusion raciale, en analysant les logiques argumentatives de discours différentialistes et en interrogeant les discours qui sont formulés de façon « acceptable » en tant qu’outils (potentiels) d’exclusion raciale. Nous avons analysé des discours pancanadiens mis en circulation dans des articles de médias (n = 2437), des publications d’autorités sanitaires (n = 533) et des commentaires publiés par des internautes (n = 3441) lors d’éclosions internationales de tuberculose, d’H1N1, d’Ebola et du Zika. Par une analyse rhétorique des cadres, nos résultats montrent que l’exclusion raciale s’opère par trois axes de catégorisation (le risque sanitaire posé par l’appartenance nationale, les attributs et le rapport épistémique), les deux premiers étant objets de critiques et de désapprobation sociale, et le dernier servant d’argument principal pour justifier une exclusion raciale. Nous problématisons cet usage discursif comme l’articulation d’un racisme limite commode dans une atmosphère rhétorique de « crainte de post-vérité ».
Mots-clés :
- Épidémie,
- blâme,
- héroïsation,
- nouveau racisme,
- post-vérité
Abstract
Studies on othering in times of epidemics show a recurrent appropriation of disease outbreaks to reproduce racial exclusions. Inspired by new racism studies and relying on the conceptual tool of “borderline racism,” this article focuses on the argumentative normativity of this racial exclusion, by analyzing the argumentative logics of differentialist discourses, and by questioning those formulated in a seemingly “acceptable” manner as (potential) tools of racial exclusion. We analyzed pan-Canadian discourses circulated in media articles (n = 2437), publications by health authorities (n = 533) and comments posted by Internet users (n = 3441) during international outbreaks of tuberculosis, H1N1, Ebola and Zika. Through a rhetorical frame analysis, our results show that racial exclusion operates through three axes of categorization (the health risk posed by differing nationality, attributes, and epistemic standpoints), the first two being objects of criticism and social disapproval, and the latter serving as the main argument to justify racial exclusion. We problematize this discursive use as the articulation of a convenient borderline racism in a rhetorical atmosphere of “fear of post-truth.”
Keywords:
- Epidemic,
- blame,
- heroization,
- new racism,
- post-truth
Parties annexes
Bibliographie
- Abeysinghe, S., Amir, V., Huda, N., Humam, F., Lokopessy, A. F., Sari, P. V., Utami, A. et Suwandono, S. (2022). Risk and responsibility : Lay perceptions of COVID-19 risk and the ‘ignorant imagined other’ in Indonesia. Health, Risk & Society, 24(5-6), 187-207.
- Adeyanju, C. T. (2010). Deadly Fever : Racism, Disease and a Media Panic. Halifax : Fernwood Publishing.
- Agier, M. (2012). Frontiers of exile : Towards bio-political otherness. Hermes : Cognition, Communication, Politique, 63, 88-94.
- Amossy, R. (2008). Argumentation et analyse du discours : Perspectives théoriques et découpages disciplinaires. Argumentation et Analyse du Discours, 1. https://doi.org/10.4000/aad.200
- Angermüller, J. (2011). Heterogeneous knowledge : Trends in German discourse analysis against an international background. Journal of Multicultural Discourses, 6(2), 121-136.
- Atlani-Duault, L. (2009). Au bonheur des autres. Anthropologie de l’aide humanitaire. Nanterre : Société d’ethnologie.
- Atlani-Duault, L., Mercier, A., Rousseau, C., Guyot, P. et Moatti, J.-P. (2015). Blood libel rebooted : Traditional scapegoats, online media, and the H1N1 epidemic. Cultural Medical Psychiatry, 39(1), 43-61.
- Atlani-Duault, L., Dozon, J.-P., Wilson, A., Delfraissy, J.-F. et Moatti, J.-P. (2016). State humanitarian verticalism versus universal health coverage : A century of French international health assistance revisited. The Lancet, 387(10034), 2250-2262.
- Baggini, J. (2017). A Short History of Truth : Consolations for a Post-Truth World. London : Quercus.
- Balibar, E. (1991). Is there a ‘neo-racism’ ? In E. Balibar & I. Wallerstein (Eds.), Race, Nation, Class : Ambiguous Identities (pp. 17-27). London/Brooklyn : Verso.
- Barker, M. (1981). The New Racism : Conservatives and the Ideology of the Tribe. London : Junction Books.
- Barry, C. L., Jarlenski, M., Grob, R., Schlesinger, M. et Gollust, S. E. (2011). News media framing of childhood obesity in the United States from 2000 to 2009. Pediatrics, 128(1), 132-145.
- Brendese, P. J. (2014). Borderline epidemics : Latino immigration and racial biopolitics. Politics, Groups, and Identities, 2(2), 168-187.
- Briggs, C. L. et Mantini-Briggs, C. (2003). Stories in the Time of Cholera : Racial Profiling During a Medical Nightmare. Berkeley : University of California Press.
- Conway, S. (2018). From Britishness to multiculturalism : Official Canadian identity in the 1960s. Études canadiennes/Canadian Studies, 84, 9-30.
- Crawford, R. (1994). The boundaries of the self and the unhealthy other : Reflections on health, culture and AIDS. Social Science and Medicine, 38(10), 1347-1365.
- D’Angelo, P. D. et Kuypers, J. A. (Eds.). (2010). Doing News Framing Analysis : Empirical and Theoretical Perspectives. London/New York : Routledge.
- Desmarais, C., Roy, M., Nguyen, M. T., Venkatesh, V. et Rousseau, C. (2023). The unsanitary other and racism during the pandemic : Analysis of purity discourses on social media in India, France, and the United States of America during the COVID-19 pandemic. Anthropology & Medicine, 30(1), 31-47.
- Dozon, J.-P. (2017). La vérité est ailleurs : Complots et sorcellerie. Paris : Éditions Maison des sciences de l’homme.
- Dry, S. et Leach, M. (Eds.). (2010). Epidemics : Science, Governance and Social Justice. London/Washington : Earthscan.
- Echenberg, M. (2011). Africa in the Time of Cholera : A History of Pandemics from 1817 to the Present. New York : Cambridge University Press.
- Eichelberger, L. (2007). SARS and New York’s Chinatown : The politics of risk and blame during an epidemic of fear. Social Science and Medicine, 65(6), 1284-1295.
- Fairhead, J. (2016). Understanding social resistance to the Ebola response in the forest region of the Republic of Guinea : An anthropological perspective. African Studies Review, 59(3), 7-31.
- Farmer, P. (2006). AIDS and Accusations : Haiti and the Geography of Blame. Berkeley/Los Angeles : University of California Press.
- Foucault, M. (1969). L’archéologie du savoir. Paris : Gallimard.
- Foucault, M. (1971). L’ordre du discours. Paris : Gallimard.
- Garlin-Politis, F., Roy, M., Ward, J. et Atlani-Duault, L. (à paraître). Distort, post, repeat : Laundering anti-Semitism on ‘cliquey networks’ during Covid-19. Transcultural Psychiatry.
- Hall, S. (2013). La “race” : Un signifiant flottant. In M. Cervulle (Ed.), Identités et cultures 2 : Politiques des différences (pp. 95-111). Paris : Éditions Amsterdam.
- Hewlett, B. S. et Hewlett, B. L. (2008). Ebola, Culture, and Politics : The Anthropology of an Emerging Disease. Belmont : Wadsworth Cengage Learning.
- Holton, A., Weberling, B., Clarke, C. E. et Smith, M. J. (2012). The blame frame : Media attribution of culpability about the MMR-autism vaccination scare. Health Communication, 27(7), 690-701.
- Joffe, H. (2004). Risk and ‘The Other’. Cambridge : Cambridge University Press.
- Joffe, H. (2011). Public apprehension of emerging infectious diseases : Are changes afoot ? Public Understanding of Science, 20(4), 446-460.
- Klapp, O. E. (2017). Heroes, Villains, and Fools : The Changing American Character. New York : Routledge.
- Leach, C. W. (2005). Against the notion of a ‘new racism’. Journal of Community & Applied Social Psychology, 15(6), 432-445.
- Leach, M. et Fairhead, J. (2007). Vaccine Anxieties : Global Science, Child Health and Society. London : Earthscan.
- Mitman, G. (2014). Bush meat : Ebola in a stew of fear. New England Journal of Medicine, 371, 1763-1765.
- Monson, S. (2017). Ebola as African : American media discourses of panic and otherization. Africa Today, 63(3), 2-27.
- Nelkin, D. et Gilman, S. L. (1991). Placing blame for devastating disease. In A. Mack (Ed.), In Time of Plague : The History and Social Consequences of Lethal Epidemic Diseases (pp. 39-56). New York : New York University Press.
- Paturet, J.-B. (2007). Ce que nous enseigne l’étranger de la cité athénienne : Pour un autre regard. In R. Stitou (Ed.), L’étranger et le différent dans l’actualité du lien social (pp. 81-93). Nantes : Éditions Pleins Feux.
- Picard, R. et Vial, A. (2012). De l’information du patient à la démocratie sanitaire : Enjeux et conditions d’un usage efficient des technologies. Paris : Ministère de l’économie et des finances.
- Potvin, M. (2017). Discours racistes et propagande haineuse : Trois groupes populistes identitaires au Québec. Diversité Urbaine, 17, 49-72.
- Rabinow, P. (2010). L’artifice et les Lumières : De la sociobiologie à la biosocialité. Politix, 90(2), 21-46.
- Rail, G., Jette, S. et Cloos, P. (2015). The racialization of U.S. public health : A paradox of the modern state. Cultural Studies–Critical Methodologies, 15(5), 379-386.
- Reitmanova, S., Gustafson, D. et Ahmed, R. (2015). ‘Immigrants can be deadly’ : Critical discourse analysis of racialization of immigrant health in the Canadian press and public health policies. Canadian Journal of Communication, 40(3), 471-487.
- Roy, M., Moreau, N., Rousseau, C., Mercier, A., Wilson, A. et Atlani-Duault, L. (2020). Ebola and localized blame on social media : Analysis of Twitter and Facebook conversations during the 2014-2015 Ebola epidemic. Culture, Medicine and Psychiatry, 44, 56-79.
- Singh, V. (2018). Myths of meritocracy : Caste, karma, and the new racism. A comparative study. Ethnic and Racial Studies, 41(15), 2693-2710.
- Sinha, M. S. et Parmet, W. E. (2016). The perils of panic : Ebola, HIV, and the intersection of global health and law. American Journal of Law and Medicine, 42(2-3), 223-255.
- Taguieff, P.-A. (1997). Le racisme. Paris : Flammarion.
- Ungar, S. (1998). Hot crises and media reassurance : A comparison of emerging diseases and Ebola Zaire. The British Journal of Sociology, 49(1), 36-56.
- Valente, P. K., Morin, C., Roy, M., Mercier, A. et Atlani-Duault, L. (2020). Sexual transmission of Zika virus on Twitter : A depoliticized epidemic. Global Public Health, 15(11), 1689-1701.
- Wald, P. (2008). Contagious : Cultures, Carriers, and the Outbreak Narrative. Durham/London : Duke University Press.
- Washer, P. (2004). Representations of SARS in the British newspapers. Social Science and Medicine, 59, 2561-2571.
- Wight, C. (2018). Post-truth, postmodernism and alternative facts. New Perspectives, 26(3), 17-29.
- Wilkinson, A. et Fairhead, J. (2017). Comparison of social resistance to Ebola response in Sierra Leone and Guinea suggests explanations lie in political configurations, not culture. Critical Public Health, 27(1), 14-27.
- Winter, E. (2011). Us, Them, and Others : Pluralism and National Identity in Diverse Societies. Toronto : University of Toronto Press.
- Yuya, S., Narimatsu, H., Hozawa, A., Shao, L., Otani, K. et Fukao, A. (2012). Cancer patients on Twitter : A novel patient community on social media. BMC Research Notes, 5, 699.
10.7202/1047977ar