Abstracts
Abstract
This paper examines Russian and English reportage published online over the course of Wednesday, 1 September, the first day of the three-day hostage-crisis that took place in Beslan, Southern Russia in 2004. The material selected for analysis comes from three disparate news agencies: RIA-Novosti, a major, state-controlled Russian news agency; Kavkazcenter, the website of the Chechen armed resistance; and Caucasian Knot, a site founded by Memorial, Russia’s international and historical human rights society. Drawing on tenets of socio-narrative theory that combine narratological tools with the idea of ‘ontological narrativity’ (Somers and Gibson 1994: 38), the paper analyses the construction of the news narratives published by each website, before turning to a comparative analysis of the translated material also published that day. The paper thus contributes to academic knowledge regarding the Beslan hostage-taking and the discourses generated by the event – particularly those produced by fringe groups and in translation – as well as to knowledge of narrative construction as events are still occurring. Preliminary conclusions are drawn regarding the effect of translation on these competing narratives, particularly those circulated by opposition, non-mainstream groups concerning situations of violent political conflict, such as that which still continues in Chechnya and the North Caucasus.
Keywords:
- Beslan,
- Chechnya,
- Russia,
- narrative theory,
- terrorism,
- online media
Résumé
Le présent article analyse le reportage en russe et en anglais sur la prise d’otages qui frappa Beslan en Russie du Sud entre le 1er et le 3 septembre 2004, et se penche tout particulièrement sur les informations publiées en ligne au cours de la première journée de cette crise. Le corpus sélectionné et analysé provient de trois agences de presse distinctes : RIA-Novosti, une importante agence de presse russe contrôlée par l’État ; Kavkazcenter, le site web de la résistance armée tchétchène ; et Caucasian Knot, un site fondé par Memorial, l’organisation internationale et historique des droits de l’homme de Russie. L’étude a recours aux principes de la théorie narrative et allie les outils narratologiques d’analyse à la notion d’‘ontological narrativity’ (Somers et Gibson 1994 : 38) et explore la construction des récits d’information publiés par chaque site web, avant de passer à une analyse comparée de leur traduction, publiée le jour même. Ce travail contribue donc au savoir académique sur la prise d’otages de Beslan et les discours générés par l’événement – en particulier ceux qui sont produits par des groupes marginaux et par le biais de la traduction – ainsi qu’au savoir sur le processus de construction narrative, alors même que les événements sont en train de se produire. L’article tire des premières conclusions quant à l’effet de la traduction sur ces récits rivaux, particulièrement ceux qui sont diffusés par des groupes contestataires et non dominants relativement au conflit politique violent, comme celui qui perdure en Tchétchénie et dans le Caucase du Nord.
Mots-clés :
- Beslan,
- Tchétchénie,
- Russie,
- théorie narrative,
- terrorisme,
- médias en ligne
Appendices
Bibliographie
- Baker, Mona (2006): Translation and Conflict: A narrative account. London: Routledge.
- Bal, Mieke (1985/1997): Narratology: Introduction to the Theory of Narrative. Toronto, Buffalo, London: University of Toronto Press.
- Bell, Alan (1991): The Language of News Media. Oxford: Blackwell.
- Bennett, W. Lance and Edelman, Murray (1985): Toward a New Political Narrative. Journal of Communication. 35(4):156-171.
- Bhatia, Michael V. (2005): Fighting Words: Naming terrorists, bandits, rebels and other violent actors. Third World Quarterly. 26(1):5-22.
- Blandy, Charles (2004): Chechnya After Beslan. Camberley, Surrey: Conflict Studies Research Centre.
- Bruner, Jerome (1991): The Narrative Construction of Reality. Critical Inquiry. 18(1):1-21.
- Butler, Judith (2004): Precarious Life: The powers of mourning and violence. London: Verso.
- Carr, David (1986): Narrative and the Real World. History and Theory. 25(2):117-131.
- Dolnik, Adam (2007): Negotiating the Impossible? The Beslan Hostage Crisis. London: Royal United Service Institute for Defence Studies.
- Dunlop, John B. (2006): The 2002 Dubrovka and 2004 Beslan Hostage Crises. Stuttgart: ibidem-Verlag.
- Dzutsev, Khasan Vladimirovich (2008): Beslan posle 1-3 sentiabria 2004 goda: sotsiologocheskii analiz. Moscow: ROSSPEN.
- Fisher, Walter R. (1985): The Narrative Paradigm: In the Beginning. Journal of Communication. 35(4):74-89.
- Fisher, Walter R. (1987/1989): Human Communication as Narration: Toward a Philosophy of Reason, Value and Action. Columbia: University of South Carolina Press.
- Fisher, Walter R. (1997): Narration, Reason and Community. In: Lewis P. Hinchman and Sandra K. Hinchman, eds. Memory, Identity, Community: The Idea of Narrative in the Human Sciences. Albany: State University of New York Press, 307-327.
- Genette, Gérard (1972/1980): Narrative Discourse: An Essay on Method. (Translated by Jane E. Lewin) Oxford: Basil Blackwell.
- Glover, Ross (2002): The War on _______. In: Ross Glover and John Collins, eds. Collateral Language: A User’s Guide to America’s New War. New York and London: New York University Press, 207-222.
- Haraszti, Miklós (2004): Report on Russian Media Coverage of the Beslan Tragedy: Access to information and journalists’ working conditions. Organization for Security and Co-operation in Europe. Visited 16 January 2010, <http://www.osce.org/documents/rfm/2004/09/3586_en.pdf> (and also in Russian, <http://www.osce.org/documents/rfm/2004/09/3586_ru.pdf>).
- Harding, Sue-Ann (2009): News as Narrative: Reporting and Translating the 2004 Beslan Hostage Disaster. Unpublished doctoral thesis. Manchester: University of Manchester.
- Hutchings, Stephen (2009): Russia’s 9/11: Abjection, Performative Identity and Television Coverage of the Beslan Atrocity. In: Stephen Hutchings and Natalia Rulyova, eds. Television and Culture in Putin’s Russia: Remote Control. London: Routledge, 74-88.
- Lynch, Dov (2005): The Enemy is at the Gate: Russia after Beslan. International Affairs. 81(1):141-161.
- MacIntyre, Alasdair (1981): After Virtue: A Study in Moral Theory. Notre Dame: University of Notre Dame Press.
- Meteleva, Svetlana (2005): Otmorozhennyi Magas: Boevikov v Ingushetii ne otlichat’ ot sotrudnikov MVD. Moskovskii Komsomolets 14.04.2005. Visited 08 November 2006, <http://mk.ru/newshop/bask.asp?artid=106104>.
- Phillips, Timothy (2007): Beslan: The Tragedy of School No. 1. London: Granta Books.
- Plater-Zyberk, Henry (2004): Beslan – Lessons Learned? Camberley, Surrey: Conflict Studies Research Centre.
- Politkovskaya, Anna (2007): A Russian Diary. (Translated by Arch Tait) London: Harvill Secker.
- Polkinghorne, Donald E. (1988): Narrative Knowing and the Human Sciences. NewYork: State University of New York Press.
- Prince, Gerald (1987/2003): A Dictionary of Narratology. Lincoln: University of Nebraska Press.
- Ricoeur, Paul (1979): The Human Experience of Time and Narrative. Research in Phenomenology. 9:17-34.
- Rimmon-Kenan, Shlomith (1983): Narrative Fiction: Contemporary Poetics. London: Methuen.
- Russell, John (2007): Chechnya – Russia’s ‘War on Terror.’ London and New York: Routledge.
- Ryan, Marie-Laure (1993): Narrative in Real Time: Chronicle, Mimesis and Plot in the Baseball Broadcast. Narrative. 1(2):138-155.
- Smith, Mark A. (2004): Beslan: The Political Fallout. Camberley, Surrey: Conflict Studies Research Centre.
- Snetkov, Aglaya (2007): The Image of the Terrorist Threat in the Official Russian Press: the Moscow theatre crisis (2002) and the Beslan hostage crisis (2004). Europe-Asia Studies. 59(8):1349-1365.
- Somers, Margaret (1997): Deconstructing and Reconstructing Class Formation Theory: Narrativity, Relational Analysis, and Social Theory. In: John R. Hall, ed. Reworking Class. Ithaca and London: Cornell University Press, 73-105.
- Somers, Margaret R. and Gibson, Gloria D. (1994): Reclaiming the Epistemological “Other”: Narrative and the Social Constitution of Identity. In: Craig Calhoun, ed. Social Theory and the Politics of Identity. Oxford and Cambridge: Blackwell, 37-99.
- Stepanova, Ekaterina (2004): From Dubrovka to Beslan: Who is learning faster? PONARS (Programme on New Approaches to Research and Security) Policy Memo 347. Eurasian Strategy Project: Georgetown University. Visited 16 January 2010, <https://gushare.georgetown.edu/eurasianstrategy/Memos/2004/pm_0347.pdf>.
- Taylor, Charles (1989): Sources of the Self: The Making of the Modern Identity. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
- Tishkov, Valery (2004): Chechnya: Life in a War-Torn Society. Berkeley: University of California Press.
- Whitebrook, Maureen (2001): Identity, Narrative and Politics. London and New York: Routledge.