Abstracts
Abstract
This study comprehensively maps the development and trends in AI and transformative learning research in higher education from 2019-2025. Using a systematic literature review and bibliometric analysis, it answers six key questions to explore the evolution of AI integration in transformative learning. Analyzing 181 Scopus-indexed articles, the study utilizes R-studio and VOSviewer software, following the PRISMA method to assess author collaborations, theme evolution, and publication distribution. The results show a significant increase in publications on AI and transformative learning. Initially focused on general AI applications in education, research has shifted toward more specific themes like generative AI, personalized learning, and ChatGPT. Despite technological innovation, pedagogical studies on transformative learning, such as active and personalised learning, remain underexplored in AI contexts. The research also reveals that countries like India and Indonesia dominate the field, indicating regional research concentration. While AI shows potential to improve student motivation, writing skills, and personalized learning, challenges such as ethical concerns, digital literacy, and socio-cultural sensitivity persist, especially regarding academic integrity and AI dependence, which may reduce critical thinking and metacognitive reflection essential for transformative learning. This study affirms that AI must be integrated with a human-centered approach to support both learning effectiveness and critical reflection. Thus, the development of ethical frameworks, educator training, and international collaboration is crucial for the sustainable and inclusive implementation of AI in higher education. In conclusion, while AI offers significant potential for enhancing transformative learning, its successful integration into higher education requires careful consideration of ethical, pedagogical, and socio-cultural dimensions to ensure its responsible and impactful application.
Keywords:
- Artificial Intelligence,
- Transformative Learning,
- Higher Education,
- Bibliometric Insights
Appendices
Bibliography
- Abulibdeh, A., Baya Chatti, C., Alkhereibi, A., & El Menshawy, S. (2025). A Scoping Review of the Strategic Integration of Artificial Intelligence in Higher Education: Transforming University Excellence Themes and Strategic Planning in the Digital Era. European Journal of Education, 60(1), e12908.
- Abulibdeh, A., Zaidan, E., & Abulibdeh, R. (2024). Navigating the confluence of artificial intelligence and education for sustainable development in the era of industry 4.0: Challenges, opportunities, and ethical dimensions. Journal of Cleaner Production, 437, 140527.
- Agarwal, V., Verma, P., & Ferrigno, G. (2025). Education 5.0 challenges and sustainable development goals in emerging economies: A mixed-method approach. Technology in Society, 81, 102814. https://doi.org/https://doi.org/10.1016/j.techsoc.2025.102814
- Akmam, A., Hidayat, R., Mufit, F., Anshari, R., & Jalinus, N. (2023). Effect of Generative Learning Models Based on Cognitive Conflict on Students’ Creative Thinking Processes Based on Metacognitive. https://doi.org/10.1088/1742-6596/2582/1/012058
- Alahmed, Y., Abadla, R., Ameen, N., & Shteiwi, A. (2023). Bridging the gap between ethical AI implementations. International Journal of Membrane Science and Technology, 10(3), 3034–3046.
- Alkatheiri, M. S. (2022). Artificial intelligence assisted improved human-computer interactions for computer systems. Computers and Electrical Engineering, 101, 107950.
- Almuhanna, M. A. (2025). Teachers’ perspectives of integrating AI-powered technologies in K-12 education for creating customized learning materials and resources. Education and Information Technologies, 30(8), 10343–10371.
- Almulla, M. A. (2023). Constructivism learning theory: A paradigm for students’ critical thinking, creativity, and problem solving to affect academic performance in higher education. Cogent Education, 10(1), 2172929.
- Alotaibi, N. S., & Alshehri, A. H. (2023). Prospers and obstacles in using artificial intelligence in Saudi Arabia higher education institutions—The potential of AI-based learning outcomes. Sustainability, 15(13), 10723.
- Alyoussef, I. Y., Drwish, A. M., Albakheet, F. A., & Alhajhoj, R. H. (2025). AI Adoption for Collaboration: Factors Influencing Inclusive Learning Adoption in Higher Education. IEEE Access.
- Al-Zahrani, A. M., & Alasmari, T. M. (2024). Exploring the impact of artificial intelligence on higher education: The dynamics of ethical, social, and educational implications. Humanities and Social Sciences Communications, 11(1), 1–12.
- Aria, M., Le, T., Cuccurullo, C., Belfiore, A., & Choe, J. (2024). openalexR: An R-Tool for Collecting Bibliometric Data from OpenAlex. R J., 15(4), 167–180.
- Back, S., Aspuru-Guzik, A., Ceriotti, M., Gryn’ova, G., Grzybowski, B., Gu, G. H., Hein, J., Hippalgaonkar, K., Hormázabal, R., & Jung, Y. (2024). Accelerated chemical science with AI. Digital Discovery, 3(1), 23–33.
- Balaid, A., Abd Rozan, M. Z., Hikmi, S. N., & Memon, J. (2016). Knowledge maps: A systematic literature review and directions for future research. International Journal of Information Management, 36(3), 451–475.
- Bartolomé, A., Castañeda, L., & Adell, J. (2018). Personalisation in educational technology: the absence of underlying pedagogies. International Journal of Educational Technology in Higher Education, 15, 1–17.
- Bhat, W. A., Khan, N. L., Manzoor, A., Dada, Z. A., & Qureshi, R. A. (2023). How to Conduct bibliometric analysis using R-studio: a practical guide. European Economic Letters (EEL), 13(3), 681–700.
- Bradford, S. C. (1934). Sources of information on specific subjects. Engineering, 137, 85–86.
- Briese, P., Evanson, T., & Hanson, D. (2020). Application of Mezirow’s transformative learning theory to simulation in healthcare education. Clinical Simulation in Nursing, 48, 64–67.
- Bucea-Manea-Țoniş, R., Kuleto, V., Gudei, S. C. D., Lianu, C., Lianu, C., Ilić, M. P., & Păun, D. (2022). Artificial intelligence potential in higher education institutions enhanced learning environment in Romania and Serbia. Sustainability, 14(10), 5842.
- Bukar, U. A., Sayeed, M. S., Razak, S. F. A., Yogarayan, S., Amodu, O. A., & Mahmood, R. A. R. (2023). A method for analyzing text using VOSviewer. MethodsX, 11, 102339.
- Campbell, L., & Brysiewicz, P. (2017). Reflections on palliative care, transformative education and Mezirow’s transformative learning theory. Africa Journal of Nursing and Midwifery, 19(3), 13-pages.
- Cantú-Ortiz, F. J., Galeano Sánchez, N., Garrido, L., Terashima-Marin, H., & Brena, R. F. (2020a). An artificial intelligence educational strategy for the digital transformation. International Journal on Interactive Design and Manufacturing (IJIDeM), 14, 1195–1209.
- Cantú-Ortiz, F. J., Galeano Sánchez, N., Garrido, L., Terashima-Marin, H., & Brena, R. F. (2020b). An artificial intelligence educational strategy for the digital transformation. International Journal on Interactive Design and Manufacturing (IJIDeM), 14, 1195–1209.
- Chasokela, D. (2025). Harnessing artificial intelligence: Transformative technologies in contemporary higher education. Journal of Computers for Science and Mathematics Learning, 2(1), 26–37.
- Chen, L., Chen, P., & Lin, Z. (2020). Artificial intelligence in education: A review. Ieee Access, 8, 75264–75278.
- Christie, M., Carey, M., Robertson, A., & Grainger, P. (2015). Putting transformative learning theory into practice. Australian Journal of Adult Learning, 55(1), 9–30.
- Chugh, R., Turnbull, D., Morshed, A., Sabrina, F., Azad, S., Md Mamunur, R., Kaisar, S., & Subramani, S. (2025). The Promise and Pitfalls: A Literature Review of Generative Artificial Intelligence as a Learning Assistant in ICT Education. Computer Applications in Engineering Education, 33(2), e70002.
- Cox, R. C. (2021). Grounding Transformative Learning Through Assessment: TROPOS (TRansformative Outcomes and PrOcesses Scale). Journal of Transformative Education, 19(4), 383–399. https://doi.org/10.1177/15413446211045163
- Dahl, J. E., & Mørch, A. (2025). A theoretical and empirical analysis of tensions between learning objects and constructivism. Education and Information Technologies, 1–50.
- Dirkx, J. M. (1998). Transformative learning theory in the practice of adult education: An overview. PAACE Journal of Lifelong Learning, 7, 1–14.
- Ezzaim, A., Dahbi, A., Aqqal, A., & Haidine, A. (2024). AI-based learning style detection in adaptive learning systems: a systematic literature review. Journal of Computers in Education, 1–39.
- Flores-Viva, J.-M., & García-Peñalvo, F.-J. (2023). Reflections on the Ethics, Potential, and Challenges of Artificial Intelligence in the Framework of Quality Education (SDG4). Comunicar: Media Education Research Journal, 31(74), 35–44.
- George, B., & Wooden, O. (2023a). Managing the strategic transformation of higher education through artificial intelligence. Administrative Sciences, 13(9), 196.
- George, B., & Wooden, O. (2023b). Managing the strategic transformation of higher education through artificial intelligence. Administrative Sciences, 13(9), 196.
- Ghnemat, R., Shaout, A., & Abrar, M. (2022). Higher Education Transformation for Artificial Intelligence Revolution: Transformation Framework. Int. J. Emerg. Technol. Learn., 17(19), 224–241.
- Goktas, P., & Grzybowski, A. (2025). Shaping the future of healthcare: Ethical clinical challenges and pathways to trustworthy AI. Journal of Clinical Medicine, 14(5), 1605.
- Gudyanga, R. (2024). Research Trends and Gaps in the Adoption of Immersive Reality Technologies in African Education Systems. International Journal of Learning, Teaching and Educational Research, 23(11), 232–253.
- Gunnlaugson, O., Cueto de Souza, R., Zhao, S., Yee, A., Scott, C., & Bai, H. (2023). Revisiting the Nature of Transformative Learning Experiences in Contemplative Higher Education. Journal of Transformative Education, 21(1), 84–101. https://doi.org/10.1177/15413446211067285
- Gupta, S., Kanaujia, A., Lathabai, H. H., Singh, V. K., & Mayr, P. (2024). Patterns in the growth and thematic evolution of Artificial Intelligence research: a study using Bradford distribution of productivity and path analysis. International Journal of Intelligent Systems, 2024(1), 5511224.
- Hagos, H. G., Lesjak, D., Flogi, A., & Ravindra Babu, B. (2025). Artificial Intelligence in Knowledge Management for Higher Education: Transformative Impact, Challenges, and Future Directions Post-COVID-19. Journal of Information Systems Engineering and Management, 10(3s), 344–359. https://doi.org/10.52783/JISEM.V10I3S.414
- Hasanein, A. M., & Sobaih, A. E. E. (2023). Drivers and consequences of ChatGPT use in higher education: Key stakeholder perspectives. European Journal of Investigation in Health, Psychology and Education, 13(11), 2599–2614.
- Henukh, A., Setiawan, A., Rusdiana, D., Syukri, M., & Agustin, M. (2024). Transformative Learning in Science Education: Bibliometric Analysis. Asian Journal of Science Education, 6(2), 1–10.
- Hodge, S. (2014). Transformative learning as an “inter-practice” phenomenon. Adult Education Quarterly, 64(2), 165–181.
- Hodgson, D., Goldingay, S., Boddy, J., Nipperess, S., & Watts, L. (2022). Problematising artificial intelligence in social work education: Challenges, issues and possibilities. The British Journal of Social Work, 52(4), 1878–1895.
- Ilić, J., Ivanović, M., & Klašnja-Milićević, A. (2024). The Impact of ChatGPT on Student Learning Experience in Higher STEM Education: A Systematic Literature Review. 2024 21st International Conference on Information Technology Based Higher Education and Training (ITHET), 1–9.
- Illeris, K. (2014). Transformative learning and identity. Journal of Transformative Education, 12(2), 148–163.
- Imran, M., Almusharraf, N., Abdellatif, M. S., & Abbasova, M. Y. (2024). Artificial intelligence in higher education: Enhancing learning systems and transforming educational paradigms.
- Iyer-Raniga, U., & Andamon, M. M. (2016). Transformative learning: Innovating sustainability education in built environment. International Journal of Sustainability in Higher Education, 17(1), 105–122.
- Karimah, S. N., & Hasegawa, S. (2022). Automatic engagement estimation in smart education/learning settings: a systematic review of engagement definitions, datasets, and methods. Smart Learning Environments, 9(1), 31.
- Katsamakas, E., Pavlov, O. V, & Saklad, R. (2024). Artificial intelligence and the transformation of higher education institutions: A systems approach. Sustainability, 16(14), 6118.
- Kitchenham, A. (2008). The evolution of John Mezirow’s transformative learning theory. Journal of Transformative Education, 6(2), 104–123.
- Kurnia, R. P. (2021). A case for Mezirow’s transformative learning. Diligentia: Journal of Theology and Christian Education, 3(1), 73–82.
- Lawani, S. M. (1981). Bibliometrics: Its theoretical foundations, methods and applications. Libri, 31(Jahresband), 294–315.
- Leal Filho, W., Lange Salvia, A., Beynaghi, A., Fritzen, B., Ulisses, A., Avila, L. V., Shulla, K., Vasconcelos, C. R. P., Moggi, S., & Mifsud, M. (2024). Digital transformation and sustainable development in higher education in a post-pandemic world. International Journal of Sustainable Development & World Ecology, 31(1), 108–123.
- Lin, C.-C., Huang, A. Y. Q., & Lu, O. H. T. (2023). Artificial intelligence in intelligent tutoring systems toward sustainable education: a systematic review. Smart Learning Environments, 10(1), 41.
- Liñán, F., & Fayolle, A. (2015). A systematic literature review on entrepreneurial intentions: citation, thematic analyses, and research agenda. International Entrepreneurship and Management Journal, 11, 907–933.
- Lytras, M. D., Serban, A. C., Alkhaldi, A., Aldosemani, T., & Malik, S. (2024). Transformative Learning for Future Higher Education: The Artificial Intelligence-enabled Learning Revolution 2035. In Digital Transformation in Higher Education, Part B (pp. 231–241). Emerald Publishing Limited.
- Malik, A. R., Pratiwi, Y., Andajani, K., Numertayasa, I. W., Suharti, S., & Darwis, A. (2023). Exploring artificial intelligence in academic essay: higher education student’s perspective. International Journal of Educational Research Open, 5, 100296.
- Mezirow, J. (2018). Transformative learning theory. In Contemporary theories of learning (pp. 114–128). Routledge.
- Milazzo, L., & Soulard, J. (2024). Bridging disciplinary perspectives on transformation: Epistemologically evaluating liminality and transformative learning. Annals of Tourism Research, 104. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.annals.2023.103710
- Mishra, M., Desul, S., Santos, C. A. G., Mishra, S. K., Kamal, A. H. M., Goswami, S., Kalumba, A. M., Biswal, R., da Silva, R. M., & Dos Santos, C. A. C. (2024). A bibliometric analysis of sustainable development goals (SDGs): a review of progress, challenges, and opportunities. Environment, Development and Sustainability, 26(5), 11101–11143.
- Mohamed Hashim, M. A., Tlemsani, I., & Matthews, R. (2022). Higher education strategy in digital transformation. Education and Information Technologies, 27(3), 3171–3195.
- Mohebi, L. (2024). Empowering learners with ChatGPT: Insights from a systematic literature exploration. Discover Education, 3(1), 36.
- Morris, T. H. (2020). Transformative learning through mindfulness: Exploring the mechanism of change. In Australian Journal of Adult Learning (Vol. 60, Issue 1).
- Moyer, J. M., & Sinclair, A. J. (2020). Learning for sustainability: Considering pathways to transformation. Adult Education Quarterly, 70(4), 340–359.
- Msambwa, M. M., Wen, Z., & Daniel, K. (2025). The Impact of AI on the Personal and Collaborative Learning Environments in Higher Education. European Journal of Education, 60(1), e12909.
- Murtaza, M., Ahmed, Y., Shamsi, J. A., Sherwani, F., & Usman, M. (2022). AI-based personalized e-learning systems: Issues, challenges, and solutions. IEEE Access, 10, 81323–81342.
- Nedungadi, P., Tang, K.-Y., & Raman, R. (2024). The Transformative Power of Generative Artificial Intelligence for achieving the sustainable development goal of Quality Education. Sustainability, 16(22), 9779.
- Okunlaya, R. O., Syed Abdullah, N., & Alias, R. A. (2022a). Artificial intelligence (AI) library services innovative conceptual framework for the digital transformation of university education. Library Hi Tech, 40(6), 1869–1892.
- Okunlaya, R. O., Syed Abdullah, N., & Alias, R. A. (2022b). Artificial intelligence (AI) library services innovative conceptual framework for the digital transformation of university education. Library Hi Tech, 40(6), 1869–1892.
- Pedro, F., Subosa, M., Rivas, A., & Valverde, P. (2019a). Artificial intelligence in education: Challenges and opportunities for sustainable development.
- Pedro, F., Subosa, M., Rivas, A., & Valverde, P. (2019b). Artificial intelligence in education: Challenges and opportunities for sustainable development.
- Pellas, N. (2023). The influence of sociodemographic factors on students’ attitudes toward AI-generated video content creation. Smart Learning Environments, 10(1), 57.
- Pessin, V. Z., Yamane, L. H., & Siman, R. R. (2022). Smart bibliometrics: an integrated method of science mapping and bibliometric analysis. Scientometrics, 127(6), 3695–3718.
- Peters, B., & Göhlich, M. (2024). Transformative Learning Through Group Coaching. Journal of Transformative Education, 22(2), 157–179. https://doi.org/10.1177/15413446231178897
- Pouru-Mikkola, L., & Wilenius, M. (2021). Building individual futures capacity through transformative futures learning. Futures, 132. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.futures.2021.102804
- Rojo, J., Ramjan, L., George, A., Hunt, L., Heaton, L., Kaur, A., & Salamonson, Y. (2023a). Applying Mezirow’s Transformative Learning Theory into nursing and health professional education programs: A scoping review. In Teaching and Learning in Nursing (Vol. 18, Issue 1, pp. 63–71). Elsevier Inc. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.teln.2022.09.013
- Rojo, J., Ramjan, L., George, A., Hunt, L., Heaton, L., Kaur, A., & Salamonson, Y. (2023b). Applying Mezirow’s Transformative Learning Theory into nursing and health professional education programs: A scoping review. Teaching and Learning in Nursing, 18(1), 63–71.
- Rusydiana, A. S. (2021). Bibliometric analysis of journals, authors, and topics related to COVID-19 and Islamic finance listed in the Dimensions database by Biblioshiny. Science Editing, 8(1), 72–78.
- Sajja, P. S., & Sajja, P. S. (2021). Introduction to artificial intelligence. Illustrated Computational Intelligence: Examples and Applications, 1–25.
- Saliba, R. (2024). Transformation in transformative learning: A reversed experience of faculty members teaching in transnational higher education institutions in Qatar. Social Sciences and Humanities Open, 9. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ssaho.2024.100823
- Salinas-Navarro, D. E., Vilalta-Perdomo, E., Michel-Villarreal, R., & Montesinos, L. (2024). Using generative artificial intelligence tools to explain and enhance experiential learning for authentic assessment. Education Sciences, 14(1), 83.
- Sayed, W. S., Noeman, A. M., Abdellatif, A., Abdelrazek, M., Badawy, M. G., Hamed, A., & El-Tantawy, S. (2023). AI-based adaptive personalized content presentation and exercises navigation for an effective and engaging E-learning platform. Multimedia Tools and Applications, 82(3), 3303–3333.
- Sewell, K. A., Schellinger, J., & Bloss, J. E. (2023). Effect of PRISMA 2009 on reporting quality in systematic reviews and meta-analyses in high-impact dental medicine journals between 1993–2018. PLoS One, 18(12), e0295864.
- Shanthi, D., Ashok, G., Biswal, C., Udharika, S., Varshini, S., & Sindhu, G. (2025). Ai-driven adaptive it training: A personalized learning framework for enhanced knowledge retention and engagement. Metallurgical and Materials Engineering, 136–145.
- Simbolon, M., Pongkondek, J. J., & Henukh, A. (2025). AI-Driven Sociocultural Interactive Digital Module for Papua: Advancing Educational Technology to Sustainable Development Goals. IJLTER. ORG, 24(2), 543–559.
- Slavuj, V., Jakšić, D., & Ašenbrener Katic, M. (2024). Artificial Intelligence in Higher Education: Trends, Possibilities and Challenges. International Conference on Interactive Collaborative Learning, 216–227.
- Snyder, C. (2008). Grabbing hold of a moving target: Identifying and measuring the transformative learning process. Journal of Transformative Education, 6(3), 159–181.
- Song, C., Shin, S.-Y., & Shin, K.-S. (2024). Implementing the dynamic feedback-driven learning optimization framework: a machine learning approach to personalize educational pathways. Applied Sciences, 14(2), 916.
- Song, C., & Song, Y. (2023). Enhancing academic writing skills and motivation: assessing the efficacy of ChatGPT in AI-assisted language learning for EFL students. Frontiers in Psychology, 14, 1260843.
- Strielkowski, W., Grebennikova, V., Lisovskiy, A., Rakhimova, G., & Vasileva, T. (2025a). AI‐driven adaptive learning for sustainable educational transformation. Sustainable Development, 33(2), 1921–1947.
- Strielkowski, W., Grebennikova, V., Lisovskiy, A., Rakhimova, G., & Vasileva, T. (2025b). AI‐driven adaptive learning for sustainable educational transformation. Sustainable Development, 33(2), 1921–1947.
- Taylor, M. M. (n.d.). Learning Toward an Ecological Consciousness: Selected Transformative Practices.
- Thahirah, K. A., Triyuwono, I., Mulawarman, A. D., & Achsin, M. (2025). Visualization of Accounting and Indigenous People Research: A Bibliometric Review Using R. JOIV: International Journal on Informatics Visualization, 9(2), 491–503.
- Villalobos, D., Povedano-Montero, J., Fernández, S., López-Muñoz, F., Pacios, J., & del Río, D. (2022). Scientific research on verbal fluency tests: A bibliometric analysis. Journal of Neurolinguistics, 63, 101082.
- Vorobyeva, K. I., Belous, S., Savchenko, N. V, Smirnova, L. M., Nikitina, S. A., & Zhdanov, S. P. (2025). Personalized Learning through AI: Pedagogical Approaches and Critical Insights. Contemporary Educational Technology, 17(2).
- Walkington, C., & Bernacki, M. L. (2020). Appraising research on personalized learning: Definitions, theoretical alignment, advancements, and future directions. In Journal of research on technology in education (Vol. 52, Issue 3, pp. 235–252). Taylor & Francis.
- Wang, M., & Chai, L. (2018). Three new bibliometric indicators/approaches derived from keyword analysis. Scientometrics, 116, 721–750.
- Xie, Q., Li, M., & Enkhtur, A. (2024). Exploring generative AI policies in higher education: A comparative perspective from China, Japan, Mongolia, and the USA. ArXiv Preprint ArXiv:2407.08986.
- Yuan, C., Li, G., Kamarthi, S., Jin, X., & Moghaddam, M. (2022). Trends in intelligent manufacturing research: a keyword co-occurrence network based review. Journal of Intelligent Manufacturing, 33(2), 425–439.
- Zhang, J., & Zhang, Z. (2024). AI in teacher education: Unlocking new dimensions in teaching support, inclusive learning, and digital literacy. Journal of Computer Assisted Learning, 40(4), 1871–1885.
- Zupic, I., & Čater, T. (2015). Bibliometric methods in management and organization. Organizational Research Methods, 18(3), 429–472.