Abstracts
Abstract
Fifty years ago, in summer 1958, Russian authorities started a program of massive relocation of the Yupik population on the Chukchi Peninsula, Siberia. About 800 people, or roughly 70% of the small nation of 1,100 at that time, were forced to leave their home sites and were moved to other communities. Some basic facts related to the Yupik relocations of the 1950s have been known since the 1960s; but no first-hand narratives of the displaced people were ever published. The paper overviews the closing of the three largest Siberian Yupik communities of Naukan, Ungaziq (Chaplino) and Plover in 1958-1959, and the displacement of their residents as recalled from their memories and personal accounts collected by the authors during the 1970s and 1980s. The paper argues that Soviet Yupik relocations of the 1950s were unprecedented in their scale and traumatic impact, even when compared to other state-initiated resettlement programs that targeted many Inuit communities in Alaska, Canada and Greenland.
Résumé
Il y a cinquante ans, pendant l’été 1958, les autorités russes ont entrepris un programme de relocalisation massive de la population yupik de la péninsule des Tchouktches en Sibérie. Quelques 800 personnes, ou environ 70% de cette petite nation de 1100 individus à l’époque, ont été forcées de quitter leur lieu de résidence et ont été transférées vers d’autres communautés. L’essentiel des faits relatifs à la relocalisation yupik est connu depuis les années 1960 mais aucun récit de première main n’a jamais été publié. Cet article présente une vue d’ensemble de la fermeture des trois plus grands villages yupik sibériens, Naukan, Ungaziq (Chaplino) et Plover en 1958-1959 ainsi que du déplacement de leurs résidents, à travers leurs souvenirs et leurs récits personnels que les auteurs ont recueillis durant les années 1970 et 1980. L’article soutient que ces relocalisations yupik par les autorités soviétiques dans les années 1950 ont été sans précédent en terme d’échelle et d’effet traumatisant, même si on les compare aux programmes de repeuplement initiés par d’autres États qui visaient de nombreuses communautés inuit en Alaska, au Canada et au Groenland.
Appendices
Archival sources
- CHUKCHI DISTRICT ARCHIVES (CDA), 1958 Ispolkom Naukanskogo soveta deputatov trudiashchikhsia. Protokoly zasedanii, 1954-1958 (‘Naukan Council Executive Committee. Minutes of the Meetings, 1954-1958’), Lavrentiya, Chukchi District Archives.
- STATE ARCHIVES OF THE CHUKOTKA AUTONOMOUS REGION (SACAR), 1939 Spiski naselennykh mest Chukotskogo raiona Kamchatskoi oblasti Dal’nevostochnogo kraia (‘The List of Inhabited Sites [Villages and Camps] of the Chukchi District, Kamchatka Province, Far-Eastern Region’), Anadyr, State Archives of the Chukotka Autonomous Region, coll. 13, reg. 1, file 11.
- STATE ARCHIVES OF THE CHUKOTKA AUTONOMOUS REGION (SACAR), 1946 Svedeniia o chislennosti i sostave naseleniia Chukotskogo raiona na 1 janvaria 1942-45 gg. (‘Data on the Population Number and the Composition of the Residents of the Chukchi District, January 1, 1942-January 1, 1945’), Anadyr, State Archives of the Chukotka Autonomous Region, coll. 26, reg. 1, file 3.
- STATE ARCHIVES OF THE CHUKOTKA AUTONOMOUS REGION (SACAR), 1951 Dinamika razvitiia narodnogo khoziaistva Chukotskogo raiona (‘Progress in the Economy of the Chukchi District. Basic Statistical Data’), Anadyr, State Archives of the Chukotka Autonomous Region, coll. P-25, reg. 1, file 1.
- STATE ARCHIVES OF THE CHUKOTKA AUTONOMOUS REGION (SACAR), 1952 Protokoly zasedanii Chukotskogo okrispolkoma za iul’-dekabr’ 1952 g. (‘Minutes of the Sessions of the Chukchi Region Executive Committee, July-December 1952’), Anadyr, State Archives of the Chukotka Autonomous Region, coll. P-1, reg.1, file 167.
- STATE ARCHIVES OF THE CHUKOTKA AUTONOMOUS REGION (SACAR), 1953 Materialy o sostoianii i razvitii sel’skogo khoziaistva za 1951-1958 gg. (‘Data on Economic Development [in Chukotka], 1951-1958’), Anadyr, State Archives of the Chukotka Autonomous Region, coll. 23, reg. 1, file 46.
- STATE ARCHIVES OF THE CHUKOTKA AUTONOMOUS REGION (SACAR), 1958 Reshenie Chukotskogo Raiispolkoma ob uprazdnenii Naukanskogo sel’skogo soveta (‘Decree of the Chukchi District Executive Committee on the Liquidation of the Naukan Village Council’), Anadyr, State Archives of the Chukotka Autonomous Region, coll. R-1, reg. 166, file 223.
- AIVANGU, 1985[1961]Nash rodnoi UngazikHuangkuta megnunalghe nunaghhtaghhput Ungaziq (‘Our beloved Ungaziq’), Magadan, Magadanskoe knizhnoe izdatelstvo.
- ANONYMOUS, 1999 Ottawa Needs Policy on Aboriginal Relocations, Nunatsiaq News, October 19. (Online version at http://www.nunatsiaq.com/archives/archives.html)
- BARR, William, 1977 Eskimo Relocation: The Soviet Experience on Ostrov Vrangelya, Musk-Ox, 20: 9-20.
- BOGORAS, Waldemar G., 1904 The Chukchee. Material Culture, in Franz Boas (ed.), The Jesup North Pacific Expedition, vol. 7, part 1, Leiden, E.J. Brill, New York, G.E. Stechert, Memoirs of the American Museum of Natural History, 11: 1-276.
- BUGAI, Nikolai F., 1989 K voprosu o deportatsiiakh narodov SSSR v 30-40-kh godakh (‘On the Issue of Ethnic Deportations in the USSR during the 1930s and 1940s’), Istoriia SSSR, 6: 135-144.
- CHICHLO, Boris, 1981 Les Nevuqaghmiit ou la fin d’une ethnie, Études/Inuit/Studies, 5(2): 29-47.
- CSONKA, Yvon, 1995 Les Ahiarmiut. À l’écart des Inuit Caribous, Neuchâtel, Éditions Victor Attinger.
- GRAY, Patty A., 2005 The Predicament of Chukotka’s Indigenous Movement. Post-Soviet Activism in the Russian Far North. Cambridge, Cambridge University Press.
- HUGHES, Charles C., 1984 Siberian Eskimo, in David Damas (ed.), Handbook of North American Indians, volume 5, Arctic, Washington, Smithsonian Institution: 247-261.
- JENNESS, Diamond, 1964 Eskimo Administration: II. Canada, Arctic Institute of North America, Technical Paper, 14.
- KERTTULA, Anna M., 2000 Antler on the Sea. The Yup’ik and Chukchi of the Russian Far East, Ithaca and London, Cornell University Press.
- KLEIN, Rüdiger, Reija TUOMAALA and Piers VITEBSKY (eds), 2008 Histories from the North: Environments, Movements, Narratives (BOREAS). Programme report, Strasbourg, European Science Foundation. (Online version at: http://www.esf.org/fileadmin/be_user/activities/EUROCORES/BOREAS/Networking/Boreas%20report_last%20version.pdf)
- KOHLHOFF, Dean, 1995 When the Wind Was a River: Aleut Evacuation in World War II, Seattle, University of Washington Press.
- KRAUSS, Michael E., 1973 Eskimo-Aleut, in Thomas Sebeok (ed.), Linguistics in North America, The Hague, Mouton, Current Trends in Linguistics, 10(2): 796-902.
- KRAUSS, Michael E., 1974 Siberian Eskimo Settlements and Populations, 1895-1970, Unpublished manuscript in authors’ possession.
- KRAUSS, Michael E., 1994 Crossroads? A Twentieth Century History of Contacts across the Bering Strait, in William Fitzhugh and Valérie Chaussonnet (eds), Anthropology of the North Pacific Rim, Washington, Smithsonian Institution Press: 365-379.
- KRUPNIK, Igor, 1983 Drevnie i traditsionnye poseleniia eskimosov na iugo-vostoke Chukotskogo poluostrova (‘Ancient and Traditional Eskimo Settlements on the South-Eastern Chukchi Peninsula’), in V.P. Alekseev (ed.), Na styke Chukotki i Aliaski, Moscow, Nauka: 65-95.
- KRUPNIK, Igor, 1994 ‘Siberians’ in Alaska. Siberian Eskimo Contribution to the Alaskan Population Recoveries, 1880-1940, Études/Inuit/ Studies, 18(1-2): 49-80.
- KRUPNIK, Igor (compiler), 2000 Pust’ govoriat nashi stariki. Rasskazy aziatskikh eskimosov-yupik. Zapisi 1975–1987 gg. (‘Let Our Elders Speak. Stories of the Yupik Eskimo, 1975-1987’), Moscow, Russian Institute of Cultural and Natural Heritage.
- KRUPNIK, Igor I. and Mikhail A. CHLENOV, 1979 Dinamika etnolingvisticheskoi situatsii u aziatskikh eskimosov (konets 19 veka-1970-e gody) (‘Dynamics of the Ethno-Linguistic Situation among the Asiatic Eskimo [from the late 19th Century and up to the 1970s]’), Sovetskaia etnografiia, 2: 19-29.
- KRUPNIK, Igor I. and Mikhail A. CHLENOV, 1996 Survival in Contact: Yupik (Asiatic Eskimo) Transitions, 1900-1990. Unpublished manuscript in authors’ possession.
- KRUPNIK, Igor and Elena MIKHAILOVA, 2006 Landscapes, Faces, and Memories: Eskimo Photography of Aleksandr Forshtein, 1927-1929, Alaska Journal of Anthropology, 4(1-2): 92–113.
- LEONT’IEV, Vladilen V., 1973 Khoziaistvo i kul’tura narodov Chukotki (1958-1970 gg.) (‘Economy and Culture of the Native People of Chukotka, 1958-1970’), Novosibirsk, Nauka.
- MARCUS, Alan R., 1992 Out in the Cold. The Legacy of Canada’s Inuit Relocation Experiment in the High Arctic, Copenhagen, IWGIA, IWGIA Document, 71.
- MARCUS, Alan R., 1995 Relocating Eden: The Images and Politics of Inuit Exile in the Canadian Arctic, Hanover, University Press of New England.
- MENOVSHCHIKOV, Georgii A., 1959 Eskimosy. Nauchno-populiarnyi istoriko-etnograficheskii ocherk ob aziatskikh eskimosakh (‘The Eskimo. Popular Historical and Ethnographic Account on the Asiatic Eskimo’). Magadan, Magadan Publishing House.
- MENOVSHCHIKOV, Georgii A., 1988 Sud’ba Naukana (‘The Fate of Naukan’), Magadanskaia pravda, 251(15929): 2.
- MOWAT, Farley, 1963a Liudi olen’ego kraia (‘People of the deer’), Moscow, Inostrannaia literatura (originally published in English in 1952).
- MOWAT, Farley, 1963b Otchaiavshiisia narod (‘The desperate people’), Moscow, Inostrannaia literatura (originally published in English in 1963).
- RASMUSSEN, Knud, 1927 Across Arctic America. Narrative of the Fifth Thule Expedition, New York, G.P. Putnam’s Sons (1999 reprint by the University of Alaska Press).
- RYTKHEU, Yuri S., 1963 Nunivak, Moscow, Molodaia gvardiia.
- SCHWEITZER, Peter P., 1997 Review of Marcus, Alan R., Relocating Eden: The Images and Politics of Inuit Exile in the Canadian Arctic, Ethnohistory, 44(2): 401–402.
- SELITRENNIK, Eduard Y., 1965 Nekotorye voprosy kolkhoznogo stroitel’stva v Chukotskom natsional’nom okruge (‘Issues in Development of the Collective Farm System in the Chukchi National Region’), Sovetskaia etnografiia, 1: 13-27.
- SMOLIAK, Anna V., 1957 Materialy k kharakteristike sotsialisticheskoi kul’tury i byta korennogo naseleniia Chukotskogo raiona (‘Data on the New Mode of Socialist Culture and Way of Life of the Native People of the Chukchi District’), in B. Dolgikh (ed.), Sibirskii etnograficheskii sbornik 2, Moscow and Leningrad, Trudy Instituta etnografii, 35: 3-37.
- TESTER, Frank J. and Peter KULCHYSKI, 1994 Tammarniit (Mistakes): Inuit Relocation in the Eastern Arctic, 1939-63, Vancouver, UBC Press.
- USHAKOV, Georgii A., 1972 Ostrov metelei (‘The Island of Blizzards’), Leningrad, Gidrometeoizdat.
- VAKHTIN, Nikolai B., 1994 Native Peoples of the Russian Far North, in Polar peoples. Self-Determination and Development, London, Minority Rights Publications: 29-80.
- VOLFSON, Aleksandr G., 1979 Analiz prichin smertnosti korennogo i prishlogo naseleniia Chukotskogo avtonomnogo okruga (‘Analyses of the Causes of Death for the Native and Newcomer Population of the Chukotka Autonomous Region’), unpublished report, Magadan, Institut biologicheskikh problem Severa.