Résumés
Résumé
Le maintien de la paix multilatéral est, de plus en plus fréquemment, le moyen par lequel la communauté internationale répond aux conflits violents, qu’ils soient internes ou entre États. L’étude du maintien de la paix requiert des investigations transnationales et multi-sites dont l’importance est croissante en anthropologie. En dépit de ce fait, peu d’études anthropologiques du maintien de la paix ont été réalisées. Cet article prolonge un programme ininterrompu de recherche anthropologique sur le maintien de la paix. Il utilise la théorie de l’inversion psychologique pour interpréter des données ethnographiques recueillies par l’Organisme des Nations Unies chargé de la surveillance de la trêve (ONUST). Dans le maintien de la paix, les actions individuelles sont liées, dans un processus d’implications mutuelles, à des schémas à grande échelle de légitimité et d’efficacité du maintien de la paix. L’analyse présentée ici crée un échafaudage théorique permettant de connecter l’analyse des motivations au niveau individuel à un exposé de l’inversion culturelle dans le maintien de la paix à de plus hauts niveaux d’organisation sociale.
Mots clés:
- Rubinstein,
- maintien de la paix,
- motivation,
- agir et structure,
- analyse multiniveaux,
- inversion culturelle
Abstract
Multilateral peacekeeping is an increasingly important way that the international community responds to violent conflicts within and between states. Studying peacekeeping requires transnational, multisided investigation, which is increasingly important for anthropology. Despite this, there have been few anthropological studies of peacekeeping. This paper extends an ongoing program of anthropological research on peacekeeping. This paper uses psychological reversal theory to interpret ethnographic data collected from the United Nations Truce Supervision Organization. Individual actions in peacekeeping are linked in a mutually implicative process to broad-scale patterns of peacekeeping legitimacy and effectiveness. The analysis presented here creates a theoretical scaffolding to connect the analysis of motivation at an individual level to a cultural inversion account of peacekeeping at higher levels of social organization.
Keywords:
- Rubinstein,
- peacekeeping,
- motivation,
- structure and agency,
- multi-level analysis,
- cultural inversion
Resumen
El mantenimiento multilateral de la paz es el medio que, con mayor frecuencia, utiliza la comunidad internacional en tanto que respuesta a los conflictos violentos, sean internos o entre naciones. El estudio del mantenimiento de la paz exige investigaciones trasnacionales y multi-situacionales, que son cada día más importantes en antropología. A pesar de ello, se han realizado pocos estudios antropológicos sobre el mantenimiento de la paz. Este artículo prolonga un continuo programa de investigación antropológica sobre el mantenimiento de la paz. Utiliza la teoría de la inversión sicológica en la interpretación de los datos etnográficos recogidos por la Organización de la Naciones Unidas encargada de la vigilancia de la tregua (ONUVT). En el mantenimiento de la paz, las acciones individuales están ligadas, al interior de un proceso de implicaciones mutuas, con esquemas a gran escala de legitimidad y eficacia del mantenimiento de la paz. El análisis que aquí se presenta, propone un andamiaje teórico que permite conectar el análisis de las motivaciones a escala individual con una explicación de la inversión cultural en el mantenimiento de la paz a niveles más altos de la organización social
Palabras clave:
- Rubinstein,
- mantenimiento de la paz,
- motivación,
- acción y estructura,
- análisis multi-niveles,
- inversión cultural
Parties annexes
Références
- Apter M. J., 1989, Reversal Theory : Motivation, Emotion and Personality. Londres, Routledge.
- Apter M. J., D. Fontana et S. Murgatroyd (dir.), 1985, Reversal Theory : Applications and Developments. Cardiff, University College Cardiff Press.
- Babcock B., 1978a, « Liberty’s a Whore : Inversions, Marginalia and Picaresque Narrative » : 95-116, in B. A. Babcock (dir.), The Reversible World. Ithaca, Cornell University Press.
- Babcock B. (dir.), 1978b, The Reversible World. Ithaca, Cornell University Press.
- Bateson G., 1972, Steps to an Ecology of Mind : Collected Essays in Anthropology, Psychiatry, Evolution and Epistemology. New York, Chandler.
- —, 1979, Mind and Nature : A Necessary Unity. New York, Dutton.
- Bateson M. C., 1988, « Compromise and the Rhetoric of Good and Evil » : 35-46, in R. A. Rubinstein et M. L. Foster (dir.), The Social Dynamics of Peace and Conflict. Culture in International Security. Boulder, Westview Press.
- Bauman R. D. A. R., 1972, « Ranges of Festival Behavior » : 193-208, in B. Babcock (dir.), The Reversible World. Ithaca, Cornell University Press.
- Bourdieu P., 1990, The Logic of Practice. Stanford, Stanford University Press.
- Chopra J., 2000, « The UN’s Kingdom of East Timor », Survival, 42 : 27-40.
- d’Aquili E., C. D. Laughlin et J. McManus (dir.), 1978, The Spectrum of Ritual : A Biogenetic Structural Analysis. New York, Columbia University Press.
- Davis N. Z., 1975, « Women on Top : Symbolic Sexual Inversion and Political Disorder in Early Modern Europe » : 147-190, in B. Babcock (dir.), The Reversible World. Ithaca, Cornell University Press.
- Dirks R., 1978, « Resource Fluctuations and Competitive Transformations in West Indian Slave Societies » : 122-180, in C. D. Laughlin et I. Brady (dir.), Extinction and Survival in Human Populations. New York, Columbia University Press.
- —, 1988, « Annual Rituals of Conflict », American Anthropologist, 90 : 856-870.
- Geisel T. S., 1950, Yertle the Turtle and Other Stories. New York, Random House.
- Ghosh A., 1994, « The Global Reservation : Notes Toward an Ethnography of International Peacekeeping », Cultural Anthropology, 9 : 412-422.
- Heiberg M., 1990, « Peacekeepers and Local Populations : Some Comments on UNIFIL » : 147-169, in I. J. Rikhye et K. Skjelsbaek (dir.), The United Nations and Peacekeeping. Results, Limitations and Prospects. Londres, Macmillan.
- Heiberg M. et J. Holst, 1986, « Peacekeeping in Lebanon : Comparing UNIFIL and the MNF », Survival, 28 : 410-411.
- Kashima Y., 1997, « Culture, Narrative, and Human Motivation» : 16-30, in D. Munro, J. F. Schumaker et C. C. Stuart (dir.), Motivation and Culture. Londres, Routledge.
- Kirsch I., 1999, « Response Expectancy : An Introduction » : 3-13, in I. Kirsch (dir.), How Expectancies Shape Experience. Washington, American Psychological Association.
- Kuper H., 1947, « The Drama of Kingship » : 197-225, in H. Kuper (dir.), An African Aristocracy. New York, Africana Publishing Company.
- Laughlin C. D., J. McManus et E. d’Aquili, 1990, Brain, Symbol and Experience : Toward a Neurophenomenology of Human Consciousness. Boston, New Science Library, Shambala Books.
- Maturana H. R. et F. J. Varela, 1988, The Tree of Knowledge : The Biological Roots of Human Understanding. Boston, New Science Library.
- Munro D., 1997, « Levels and Processes in Motivation and Culture » : 3-15, in D. Munro, J. F. Schumaker et C. C. Stuart (dir.), Motivation and Culture. Londres, Routledge.
- Myerhoff B. G., 1978, « Return to Wirikuta : Ritual Reversal and Symbolic Continuity on the Peyote Hunt of the Huichol Indians » : 225-239, in B. Babcock (dir.), The Reversible Worlds. Ithaca, Cornell University Press.
- Nordstrom C. et A. B. Fetherston, 1995, « Overcoming Habitus in Conflict Management : UN Peacekeeping and War Zone Ethnography », Peace and Change, 20 : 94-119.
- Peacock J. L., 1978, « Symbolic Reversal and Social History : Transvestites and Clowns of Java » : 209-224, in B. Babcock (dir.), The Reversible World. Ithaca, Cornell University Press.
- Rehn E. et E. J. Sirleaf, 2002, Women, War, and Peace. New York, United Nations Development Fund for Women.
- Rikhye I. J., 1984, The Theory and Practice of Peacekeeping. New York, St. Martin’s Press.
- Rubinstein R. A., 1989, « Culture, International Affairs and Peacekeeping : Confusing Process and Pattern », Cultural Dynamics, 2 : 41-61.
- —, 1993, « Cultural Aspects of Peacekeeping : Notes on the Substance of Symbols », Millennium : Journal of International Studies, 22 : 547-562.
- —, 1998a, « Methodological Challenges in the Ethnographic Study of Multilateral Peacekeeping », Political and Legal Anthropology Review, 21 : 138-149.
- —, 1998b, « Peacekeeping under Fire : Understanding the Social Construction of the Legitimacy of Multilateral Intervention », Human Peace, 11 : 22-29.
- —, 2003a, « Cross-cultural Considerations in Complex Peace Operations », Negotiation Journal, 19 : 29-49.
- —, 2003b, « Politics and Peacekeepers : Experience and Political Representation among United States Military Officers » : 15-27, in P. R. Frese et M. C. Harrell (dir.), Anthropology and the United States Military : Coming of Age in the Twenty-First Century. New York, Palgrave Macmillian.
- —, 2005, « Intervention and Culture : An Anthropological Approach to Peacekeeping », Security Dialogue, 36 : 527-544.
- Rubinstein R. A., C. D. Laughlin et J. McManus, 1984, Science as Cognitive Process : Toward an Empirical Philosophy of Science. Philadelphie, University of Pennsylvania Press.
- Rubinstein R. A. et S. Tax, 1985, « Power, Powerlessness, and the Failure of Political Realism » : 301-308, in J. Brosted, J. Dahl, A. Gray, H. C. Gullov, G. Henriksen, J. B. Jorgensen et I. Kleivan (dir.), Native Power. The Quest for Autonomy and Nationhood of Indigenous People. Bergen, Universitetsforlaget AS.
- Turner V., 1967, « Betwixt and Between : The Liminal Period in Rites de Passage » : 93-111, in V. Turner (dir.), The Forest of Symbols. Ithaca, Cornell University Press.
- —, 1969, The Ritual Process : Structure and Anti-Structure. Chicago, Aldine Publishing.
- —, 1974, Dramas, Fields and Metaphors : Symbolic Action in Human Society. Ithaca, Cornell University Press.
- —, 1978, « Comments and Conclusions » : 276-296, in B. Babcock (dir.), The Reversible Worlds. The Symbolic Inversion in Art and Society. Ithaca, Cornell University Press.
- United Nations, 1996, The Blue Helmets : A Review of United Nations Peace-keeping. New York, United Nations Publications.
- Urquhart B., 1989, Decolonization and World Peace. Austin, University of Texas Press.
- Winslow D., 1997, The Canadian Airborne Regiment in Somalia : A Socio-cultural Inquiry. Ottawa, Canadian Government Publishing.