Abstracts
Abstract
In 1809, Elizabeth Mackay was walking on the beach a short distance from her home in Reay, Caithness, when she saw a mermaid in the water. Her detailed and deeply mysterious account of what she saw caused a national sensation when it appeared in the press. Whether a hoax intended to draw investment and tourists to Caithness or a genuine document, Elizabeth Mackay’s testimony is worthy of close reading, as it documents a rare coastal encounter between a human and a marine animal and the partial connections forged between them. The first part of this article sets her observations in the context of other “strange” phenomena encountered on Scotland’s northern coastline and draws on feminist materialist approaches to read her testimony as an example of what Donna Haraway calls “situated knowledges”—partial, subjective, and most importantly, embodied encounters that oppose an Enlightenment model of all-seeing, detached objectivity. The second part traces the influence of the Caithness mermaid on literary production during the following decade by Christian Isobel Johnstone, Thomas Love Peacock, and Walter Scott. Despite attempts to memorialise the Caithness mermaid in verse, the sighting had a stronger literary afterlife in satirical fiction than it did in poetry.
Appendices
Bibliography
- Alaimo, Stacy. “Trans-Corporeal Feminisms and the Ethical Space of Nature.” Feminist Materialisms, edited by Stacy Alaimo and Susan Hekman, Indiana UP, 2008, pp. 237–64.
- “Alpha.” “The Caithness Mermaid.” Northern Ensign and Weekly Gazette, 5 February 1885, p. 2.
- “A Mermaid Seen on the Coast of Caithness.” Madras Courier, 20 February 1810, p. 8.
- “A Mermaid Seen in Caithness.” John O’Groat Journal, 20 April 1849, p. 3.
- “Another Mermaid.” Belfast Commercial Chronicle, 25 October 1809, p. 4.
- Beaton, D. Ecclesiastical History of Caithness and Annals of Caithness Parishes. William Rae, 1909.
- Benwell, Gwen, and Arthur Waugh. Sea Enchantress: The Tale of the Mermaid and her Kin. Hutchinson, 1961.
- Borlase, William. The Natural History of Cornwall. London and Oxford, 1753.
- Bunce, David. “Fauna.” The County of Caithness, edited by John Horne, Wick, W. Rae, 1907, pp. 357–66.
- Calder, James Traill. Poems from John O’Groat’s. Wick, P. Reid, 1855.
- [Canning, George, and George Ellis]. Review of Observations on the Report of the Bullion Committee, by Sir John Sinclair. Quarterly Review, November 1810, pp. 518–36.
- “City of Glasgow (County of Lanark)”. The Statistical Account of Scotland. Drawn up from the communications of the Ministers of the Different Parishes, edited by Sir John Sinclair, vol. 5, Edinburgh, William Creech, 1793, pp. 488–583.
- Donovan, Edward. The Natural History of British Fishes: Including Scientific and General Descriptions of the Most Interesting Species. London, Rivington, 1802. 5 vols.
- Donovan, Edward. The Naturalist’s Repository, or Monthly Miscellany of Exotic Natural History. London, W. Simpkin and R. Marshall, 1823–27. 5 vols.
- Dunnigan, Sarah M. “‘Strange Stories’: Collecting, Translating and Imagining Mermaids in Early Nineteenth-Century Scotland.” Sun-Yat Journal of Humanities, vol. 30, 2011, pp. 19–46.
- “Evidence Respecting the Existence of a Mermaid on the Coast of Argyle.” Scots Magazine and Edinburgh Literary Miscellany, December 1811, pp. 910–13.
- Grierson, Elizabeth. “The Seal Catcher and the Mermaid.” 1910. Scottish Folk and Fairy Tales from Burns to Buchan, edited by Gordon Jarvie, Penguin, 2008, pp. 12–17.
- Grigson, Caroline. Menagerie: The History of Exotic Animals in England. Oxford UP, 2016.
- Haraway, Donna. “Situated Knowledges: The Science Question in Feminism and the Privilege of Partial Perspective.” Feminist Studies, vol. 14, no. 3, 1988, pp. 575–99.
- Henderson, John. A General View of the Agriculture of the County of Caithness. Sherwood, Neely and Jones, 1815.
- Jenkins, Bill. “The Stronsay Beast: Testimony, Evidence and Authority in early Nineteenth-Century Natural History.” Notes and Records: The Royal Society Journal of the History of Science, vol. 77, no. 3, 2023, pp. 1–24. https://doi.org/10.1098/rsnr.2021.0050.
- Johnstone, Christian Isobel. The Saxon and the Gaël: or, the Northern Metropolis; including a view of the Lowland and Highland Character. Thomas Tegg, 1814. 4 vols.
- Kingshill, Sophia, and Jennifer Westwood. The Fabled Coast: Legends and Traditions from Around the Shores of Britain and Ireland. Random House, 2012.
- “Letters to Miss Innes of Sandside from Mrs. MacKay, daughter of the Rev. David Mackay, minister of Reay, and to Dr. Torrence from William Munro, schoolmaster of Thurso, describing a mermaid seen on the coast of Caithness.” National Records of Scotland, GD 87/2/28/1.
- Low, George. Fauna Orcadensis: or, The Natural History of the Quadruped, Birds, Reptiles and Fishes of Orkney and Shetland. Edinburgh, George Ramsey, 1813.
- Mackay, David. “Letter to Glasgow Philosophical Society.” Morning Herald, 21 October 1809, p. 3.
- Mackay, David. “Parish of Reay.” The Statistical Account of Scotland. Drawn up from the communications of the Ministers of the Different Parishes. Edited by Sir John Sinclair, vol. 7, Edinburgh, William Creech, 1793, pp. 570–79.
- Mackay, Elizabeth., and C. Mackenzie. “Letter from Miss Mackay, daughter of the Rev. David Mackay, Minister of Reay, to Mrs Innes, Dowager, of Sandside, May 25, 1809.” “Letters Descriptive of the Mermaid Seen on the Coast of Caithness.” Scots Magazine and Edinburgh Literary Miscellany, October 1809, pp. 734–35.
- Mayer, Robert. Walter Scott and Fame: Authors and Readers in the Romantic Age. Oxford UP, 2017.
- McKeever, Gerard Lee. Dialectics of Improvement: Scottish Romanticism, 1789–1831. Edinburgh UP, 2020.
- “Mermaid Seen on the Coast of Caithness.” Barbados Mercury and Bridge-Town Gazette, 13 January 1810, p. 3.
- “Mermaids, &c.” Morning Advertiser, 12 October 1809, p. 3.
- “Mermaids, or Sea-Women.” Kentish Gazette, 8 September 1809, p. 2.
- “Mermen and Mermaids.” British Press; or Morning Literary Advertiser, 16 November 1809, p. 4.
- “Mermen and Mermaids.” Sun, 23 November 1809, p. 4.
- Mitchison, Rosalind. Agricultural Sir John: The Life of Sir John Sinclair of Ulbster, 1754–1835. Geoffrey Bles, 1962.
- Mouat, Thomas, and James Barclay. “Island and Parish of Unst, in Shetland.” The Statistical Account of Scotland. Drawn up from the communications of the Ministers of the Different Parishes, edited by Sir John Sinclair, vol. 5, Edinburgh, William Creech, 1793, pp. 182–202.
- Munro, William. “Letter from Mr William Munro, Schoolmaster, of Thurso to Dr Torrence, regarding a Mermaid seen by him some years ago.” “Letters Descriptive of the Mermaid Seen on the Coast of Caithness.” Scots Magazine and Edinburgh Literary Miscellany, October 1809, pp. 735–36.
- “N.” “Monthly Memoranda in Natural History.” Scots Magazine and Edinburgh Miscellany, November 1808, pp. 805–06.
- “N.” “Monthly Memoranda in Natural History.” Scots Magazine and Edinburgh Miscellany, September 1809, pp. 845–46.
- Oppermann, Serpil. “Storied Seas and Living Metaphors in the Blue Humanities.” Configurations, vol. 27, no. 4, 2019, pp. 443–61.
- Paterson, John. Letter. “Mr Paterson and the Mermaid.” John O’Groat Journal, 27 April 1849, p. 3.
- Peacock, Thomas Love. Nightmare Abbey / Crochet Castle. Edited by Raymond Wright, Penguin, 1969.
- Pennant, Thomas. Synopsis of Quadrupeds. Chester, J. Monk, 1771.
- Pennant, Thomas. A Tour in Scotland: 1769. 4th ed., London, Benjamin White, 1776.
- Polson, Alexander. Our Highland Folklore Heritage. Inverness, The Northern Chronicle Office, 1926.
- Pontoppidan, Erik. The Natural History of Norway … in Two Parts. Translated by anonymous, London, A. Linde, 1755.
- “Proceedings of the Wernerian Natural History Society.” Scots Magazine and Edinburgh Miscellany, November 1809, pp. 803–05.
- “Prologue and Epilogue to The Tragedy of Helga.” Scots Magazine and Edinburgh Literary Miscellany, February 1812, pp. 134–35.
- Review of The Mermaid not Fabulous, being a Dissertation on the Existence, Figure, Character, and the Habits of that Phenomenon unquestionably proved by the Mermaids recently seen on the Caithness Coast, by Miss Mackay, Miss Mackenzie, Mr. Munro, and others; also the Merwoman of Haerlem, who lived sixteen Years on Land, earning her Bread by Spinning, and attended Divine Worship, &c. &c. with the natural History of the Mermaid. Critical Review, vol. 19, no. 1, 1809, pp. 109–10.
- Ritvo, Harriet. The Platypus and the Mermaid and Other Figments of the Classifying Imagination. Harvard UP, 1997.
- Rudinsky, Norma L. “Contemporary Response to the Caricature Asterias in Peacock’s Nightmare Abbey.” Notes and Queries, 222, July 1977, pp. 335–36.
- Rudinsky, Norma L. “Satire on Sir John Sinclair before Peacock’s Asterias in Nightmare Abbey.” Notes and Queries, March 1976, pp. 108–10.
- Sax, Boria. Imaginary Animals: The Monstrous, the Wonderous and the Human. Reaktion, 2013.
- Scott, Walter. The Letters of Sir Walter Scott. Edited by H. J. C. Grierson et al., Constable, 1932–37. 12 vols.
- Scott, Walter, editor. Minstrelsy of the Scottish Border: Consisting of Historical and Romantic Ballads, Collected in the Southern Counties of Scotland; With a few of a Modern Date, Founded upon Local Tradition. 4th ed., Edinburgh, Ballantyne, 1810. 3 vols.
- Scribner, Vaughn. Merpeople: A Human History. Reaktion, 2020.
- Sinclair, Catherine. Memoir of the Right Hon. Sir John Sinclair, Bart. With an account of his writings and personal exertions for social and agricultural improvement in Scotland. Edinburgh, William and Robert Chambers, 1853.
- Sinclair, Sir John. Letter to Walter Scott. 10 November 1810. National Library of Scotland, MS 3879.
- Sinclair, Thomas. “A Highland Estate, 1792–1800.” The Celtic Magazine, vol. 13, no. 151, 1888 pp. 289–96.
- Stewart, W. Grant. The Popular Superstitions and Festive Amusements of the Highlanders of Scotland. Edinburgh, Archibald Constable, 1823.
- Thomson, David. The People of the Sea: Celtic Tales of the Seal-folk. 1954. Canongate, 2000.
- [Tibbits, Charles John]. Folk-lore and Legends: Scotland. London, W. W. Gibbings, 1889.
- Winkiel, Lauren. “Introduction.” Hydro-criticism, special issue of English Language Notes, vol. 57, no. 1, 2019, pp. 1–10.
- Young, Simon. “The Reay Mermaids: In the Bay and in the Press.” Shima, vol. 12, no. 2, 2018, pp. 24–36. www.shimajournal.org/issues/v12n2/e.-Young-Shima-v12n2.pdf.