Price of the Soil: Property Values of Leaseholds and Certificates of Possession

Abstract

This paper presents the empirical analysis of property values across a sample of 228 leaseholds and 79 Certificates of Possession (CP) on 34 First Nation Reserves. The property values were benchmarked against a sample of 338 fee simple property sales in 34 comparable non-Indigenous communities. The results were that leaseholds were discounted 17-75% (with a mean of 24%) and CPs were discounted 65-98% (with a mean of 88%). Data across 14 factors was used to analyze trends in property values. Three trends were noteworthy: (1) Leasehold values were higher in communities where the community housing score (estimate of the quality of housing) was higher; (2) CP values were higher in communities where the ratio of informality was lower (estimate of the proportion of properties held by formalized rights under the Indian Act); and (3) Property values were higher when Chief and Council remuneration was higher. The steep discounts observed here must spur research into the viability of existing land tenure/registration systems on First Nation Reserves and into the merits of new institutions to serve First Nations.

Keywords:

• Business And Economics,
• Certificates,
• Civilization,
• Community,
• Discounts,
• Ethnic Interests,
• Housing,
• Indigenous peoples,
• Land tenure,
• Native North Americans,
• Property rights,
• Property values,
• Registration,
• Reserves,
• Sales,
• Trends,
• Indigenous economic leadership,
• Indigenous economic development