Some features and content are currently unavailable today due to maintenance at our service provider. Status updates

Book ReviewsComptes rendus de livres

Zani, Leah. Strike Patterns: Notes from Postwar Laos. Stanford: Redwood Press, 2022, 187 pages[Record]

  • Jen Pylypa

…more information

  • Jen Pylypa
    Carleton University

Based on Zani’s fieldwork in Laos from 2012 to 2015, Strike Patterns is a work of ethnographic fiction that is part ethnography, part novel, and part personal memoir. Its goal is to paint a portrait of Lao people coping with the after-effects of the Vietnam-American War, or more specifically, the CIA’s “secret” air war over Laos that made it the most bombed nation per capita in the history of the world. Zani, an anthropologist and author of the 2019 ethnography, Bomb Children, chooses a fictionalized account for this book. It reads similar to a movie that is “based on a true story”—one suspects that the people and events are roughly real but rewritten into a work of fiction both to disguise their identities for reasons of confidentiality and personal safety, and to provide a non-academic format in which to convey the story of post-war, ordinance-contaminated Laos to a broader audience. In Zani’s own words, the novel aims to employ the powerful “empathetic registers of literature” to convey her ethnographic research through creative methods that “compel ethical action” (vii). Zani notes that in her 2019 ethnography, she was unable to tell personal stories due to the risks of writing about real people living within the authoritarian Lao state; Strike Patterns is therefore her solution to writing a more emotionally powerful, personalized account—fictional yet grounded in ethnographic research. Cluster munitions, and the unexploded (or ready-to-explode) ordnance they leave behind, are deadly for decades after their initial use in war. In Laos, cluster bomblets litter the countryside almost 50 years after the end of the war; in other nations, they continue to initiate this journey of decades-long contamination today. From 1964 until 1973, the United States dropped more than two million tons of ordnance over Laos, bombing especially the communist side’s Ho Chi Minh Trail, which brought supplies from North Vietnam through Laos to the fighting in the South. Cluster bombs containing hundreds of mini-bomblets fell upon the countryside, up to a third of which failed to detonate, leaving behind tens of thousands of bomblets that continue to maim and kill civilians today, including children, who are attracted to the shiny metal objects. The efforts to clear these munitions and render the countryside safe remain ongoing, now five decades after the last bombs were dropped. In Strike Patterns, Zani writes in the first person to combine the story of these clearing efforts with portrayals of everyday life in Laos from her perspective as a participant-observer, interspersed with occasional linkages to her own family history of American military veterans and anti-war protesters. The phrase “strike pattern” has a dual meaning in her writing: it refers to the technical term for the pattern of physical impacts on a landscape left behind by an aerial war, patterns that are used by clearance technicians to assess the scope of their clearance task; it also refers to the pattern of sociocultural impacts of war, including “loss, safety, fear, stigma, and hope” (5). Zani’s story leads us back and forth through scenes that show us pieces of both of these “strike patterns.” While surveying the landscape with Channarong, an explosives clearance technician, she theorizes that the American bombing of Laos was not just a military strategy of war itself, but a way of destroying civilian life so as to cripple the Lao state if (and ultimately, when) it fell to communism. She goes on to describe the consequences: a desperately poor nation, impacted by decades of war, destruction, and subsequent Western trade embargoes, unaided by postwar aid, ordnance clearance efforts, or refugee assistance, and without humanitarian ordnance …